10.2 Growth in imports of goods and services
10.3 Exports of goods and services
10.4 Growth in exports of goods and services
10.5 Current-account balances
11.1 Changes in exchange rates
11.2 Changes in effective exchange rates
11.3 Changes in real effective exchange rates
12.1 Short-term interest rates
12.2 Short-term rates
13.1 Inflation in industrial countries
13.2 The Economist commodities index
13.3 Changes in producer prices
13.4 Compensation per employee in the business sector
13.5 Changes in consumer prices

128 129 130 133 148 153 156 169 170 180 193 198 201 206

INTERPRETING ECONOMIC
INDICATORS

"An economist is an expert who will know tomorrow why the things
he predicted yesterday didn't happen today. "
Dr Laurence J. Peter

All politicians seem able to demonstrate that their party presided over the fastest economic growth, the biggest fall in unemployment or the lowest inflation. Common sense suggests that they cannot all be correct. How can you interpret such claims?

This book shows how economic figures can be manipulated to demonstrate almost anything. More important, it explains how to read them, cut though any media hype and make up your mind about what they show, requiring no prior knowledge of economics or statistics. It deals with the 100 or so most important economic indicators, and answers questions such as the following.

What are they? What is GDP, the invisibles balance, the terms of trade, the labour force?

What do they cover? What is included in retail sales data, what is not in GDP, who is in the labour force?

What is their significance? What do GDP, capacity use or the terms of trade tell us?

Where and when are they are published? Should you look for weekly figures from the central bank, monthly information from a private organisation, quarterly numbers from the Department of Commerce, and so on.

How reliable are they? Reasonably reliable in the case of spending by a particular government department, reasonably unreliable in the case of the size of the labour force. Who knows how many people not registered as unemployed would come forward if jobs were suddenly available?

Will they be revised, or are the first-reported figures set in stone? For example, GDP data are revised endlessly, consumer-price data rarely.

How should they be interpreted? The most important question.





1 INTERPRETING ECONOMIC INDICATORS

Why interpret economic figures?

There are as many reasons for interpreting economic indicators as there are published statistics. You may want to:

 get the best return on investing your money;
 measure companies and their products;
 judge if the time is right to give the go-ahead to a new capital
investment project, to launch a takeover or to move into new
markets;
 get a better understanding of how an economy is performing;
 judge the government's economic policies;
 obtain a feel for an unfamiliar economy;
 compare several countries;
 make a forecast; or
 simply obtain a better understanding of the news.

The countries

This book takes a global view and is intended as a guide to interpreting economic indicators worldwide.
	Since it would be cumbersome if not impossible to list figures for all countries, the tables generally show data for the 15 largest industrial countries. Where appropriate, totals or averages are also shown for the OECD and the European Union (see definitions below).
	The same 15 countries form the basis for the economic and financial indicators published in The Economist each week. This book therefore provides the background to these figures and the historical data behind the up-to-the-minute information.

America. If at times undue attention seems to be given to America, it is because the American economy occupies such a dominant position, accounting as it does for about one-quarter of world output and over one-third of the output of the industrialised countries.
	Bankers, financiers and politicians worldwide depend on economic events in America. For example, apart from the direct effects on the major financial markets, a change in the dollar's exchange rate affects the prices of many internationally traded commodities such as oil, and influences trade balances worldwide, especially those of the 30 or so countries with currencies directly pegged to the dollar.

Country groups. In the late 1990s total world economic output was around $40,000 billion a year. Table 1.1 shows how this was

THE COUNTRIES

split among advanced and developing countries, and various other groups which are sometimes used as a basis for analysis. The terminology and definitions are internationally accepted and are used by the World Bank (ISRD) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF), among others.

Table 1.1 World output and trade, 1998

World

	Countries			GDP	exports
	no.

Advanced countries
USA
Japan
Germany
France
Italy
UK
Canada
Other advanced countries
Total advanced countries
Developing countries
Africa
Asia
Middle East and Europe
Latin America and Caribbean
Total developing countries
Total World
Miscellaneous groups
G7
EU
Eurozone
Industrial countries
	(former IMF definition)
Sub-Saharan Africa
Oil exporters, developing countries
Dynamic Asian economies
Central and Eastern Europe
Transcaucasus and Central Asia

	20.8
	7.4
	4.5
	3.4
	3.1
	3.3
	1.8
	11.0
	55.4

	3.3
	22.8
	4.7
33		8.9
128		39.8
156		100.0

44.4 19.9
15.5

23		52.0
	2.4
	3.9
	3.2
	2.7
	0.5

48 16 4
18 9

Note: The GDP shares are based on the purchasing of country GDPs.

Source: IMF.

13.8
6.5 9.3 5.7 4.8 5.6 3.6 28.6
77.9

1.8 8.1 3.4 4.4 17.7
100.0

49.3
40.3
32.0

68.1
1.4
2.9
9.3
2.8
0.3

-power-parity valuation

Developing countries and Africa. Of the 156 countries in Table 1.1, the 128 developing countries account for just over one-third of world output. Of these the 48 sub-Saharan African states account for less than one-fortieth of world output. Many of them are debt-laden, with slow economic growth and low income per head. They are used in this book as an example of one of the extremes of economic performance.

3
1 INTERPRETING ECONOMIC INDICATORS

Asia. At the other extreme, the four Asian newly industrialised countries (Nlcs) - Hong Kong, South Korea, Singapore and Taiwan - account for over 3% of world output. Their economic growth rates - and those of China (the world's seventh largest economy), Indonesia, Malaysia and Thailand - were among the highest in the world in the 1980s and 1990s, up to the "Asian crisis" of 1997.

Key regional and economic groups

Group of Seven (G7)
Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the UK and the USA, which together accounted for almost half of world GDP at the start of the 1990s. The G8 includes Russia.
European Union (EU - 15 countries)
Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden and the UK.
Eurozone (11 countries)
Eleven of the Eu's member states (Austria, Belgium, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal, and Spain) adopted a single currency, the euro, on January 1st 1999. National notes and coins will remain in circulation until 2002. Economic statistics for the Eurozone, as well as national economies, are published in The Economist each week. Some key data on the Eurozone countries are in Table 1.2.
Industrial countries (former IMF definition - 23)
Eu members plus Australia, Canada, Iceland, Japan, New Zealand, Norway, Switzerland and the USA.
Advanced countries (new IMF definition - 28)
The 23 industrial countries plus the four newly industrialised Asian economies and Israel.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD 29)
The 23 industrial countries plus the Czech Republic, Hungary, Mexico, Poland, South Korea and Turkey.
Sub-Saharan Africa
African countries without a Mediterranean coastline.
Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC - 12)
Algeria, Gabon, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Libya, Nigeria, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates and Venezuela.
Newly industrialising Asian economies (4)
Hong Kong, South Korea, Singapore and Taiwan. Visegrad four
Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland and Slovakia.

~IiE INDICATORS

Figure 1.1

Industrial countries GDP
of total, 1998

Sweden 1%
Belgium 1.G-

Source: OECD.

The term industrial countries is used in this book to refer to the DECD. Strictly speaking the two are not quite the same since the OECD includes Turkey, Mexico, Hungary, Poland and the Czech Republic, but the difference is negligible: those countries account for under 5% of OECD economic output.

The indicators

This book groups the major economic indicators together in chapters to highlight linkages and aid interpretation. These groups, which are not mutually exclusive, cover the economy and economic growth, population and employment, government fiscal policies, consumers, investment and savings, industry and commerce, external flows, exchange rates, money and interest rates, and prices and wages.
The briefs. Each chapter begins with a short introduction followed by a series of briefs covering the key indicators. Each brief begins with a few lines summarising the indicator, its significance, what to look for, the source, and so on. These summaries, which are necessarily general, focus on what might be expected from a major industrialised country, such as America, Britain, Germany or Japan, when the economy is in relatively good shape. Time periods. To aid interpretation, most of the tables show average rates of growth or another appropriate average for each of four economic cycles (see page 46). These cover a 30-year period and provide useful yardsticks for judging future trends.
Germany. Unification took place in October 1990 but it was only in 1993 that a wide range of consolidated figures was produced.

5
1 INTERPRETING ECONOMIC INDICATORS

Table 1.2 Eurozone countries, 1998

	Population			Density	GDP GDP per head Exports of
	m			population
		per sq km

Austria
Belgium
Finland
France
Germany
Ireland
Italy
Luxembourg
Netherlands
Portugal
Spain
Total

a 1997.

Source: DECD.

8.1 10.2
5.1
58.6
82.1
3.7
57.5
0.4
15.6
9.9
39.3
290.5

96 334 15
107 230 52
191 162 383 108 78
123

$bn			$ at	goods and
	purchasing-		servicesa
	power-parities % of GDP

	212.5
	250.5
	124.8
	1,433.9
	2,135.7
	83.2
	1,172.3
	16.7
	377.5
	105.9
	553.3
	6,466.3

23,985 24,097 21,659 22,091 22,835 22,509 21,739 34,536 23,082 15,266 16,740 22,594

42.3
72.9
39.8
26.6
26.8
79.7
27.3
101.2
56.0
31.4
28.4

Soviet republics. The break-up of the former USSR in 1991 increased the number of independent economies. Table 1.3 shows the relative size of the republics in 1997.

Table 1.3 The former Soviet republics, 1997

	Population		GDP
	m		$bn

Russia	147.3	394.9
Ukraine	50.7	52.6
Uzbekistan	23.7	24.2
Kazakhstan	15.8	21.3
Belarus	10.3	22.1
Azerbaijan	7.6	3.9
Tajikistan	6.0	2.0
Georgia	5.4	4.7
Turkmenistan	4.7	3.0
Kirgizstan	4.6	2.2
Moldova	4.3	2.0
Armenia	3.8	2.1
Lithuania	3.7	8.4
Latvia	2.5	6.0
Estonia	1.5	4.9

Source: World Bank.

Sources of information

SOURCES OF INFORMATION

Countless economic figures are published every day in the news media and in various special reports, such as those circulated by investment advisers and financial institutions. The information is necessarily selective, and readers may wish to go back to the original source of the statistics.

National sources. Apart from the various trade organisations such as the US National Association of Purchasing Managers or the Confederation of British Industry (CBI), each country has its own sources of official statistics.
	Sometimes the appropriate government department is self-evident; for example, labour statistics generally come from the department of employment or labour. For data which affect more than one department, such as GDP or balance of payments figures, good sources include the central bank or a central statistical agency, such as Germany's Federal Statistics Office or France's National Institute of Statistics and Economic Research (1NSEE). In America the Commerce Department is the most comprehensive source of data.
	Key statistical publications produced by official bodies in the 13 countries focused on are listed below. In general central bank sources contain monetary data and the other sources cover more general figures, but there is usually some overlap between the two. These official sources frequently include a summary of the major private-sector figures. For example, Britain's Economic Trends reproduces some cBl data.

International sources. International organisations publish various national and international data, frequently in standardised or semi-standardised form, within a few weeks of their original release. Key sources include the following. Website details are given in Appendix A, on page 212.

OECD. The monthly Main Economic Indicators covers output, prices and trade in the OECD's 29 member countries. The numbers are often rebased (for example, to 1995=100), but are derived from the original national data. Periodic Economic Surveys and special reports provide data and analysis relating to economic developments in one member country or to one group of indicators such as employment data.
IMF. The monthly International Financial Statistics covers monetary data and some other figures such as GDP and trade for the 182 IMF member countries. Special reports covering such indicators as exchange rates are published occasionally.
UN (United Nations). The Monthly Bulletin of Statistics includes some production and trade figures for a wide range of countries in more detail than 1rtF figures. Data on the production of various commodities are interesting.
European Commission. The monthly Eurostat contains comparative data for Eu member countries, while the quarterly European Economy includes statistics and ad hoc reports.

Useful national statistical publications

Australia Reserve Bank: Report and Financial Statement; Statistical Bulletin Australian Bureau of Statistics: Monthly Review of Business Statistics; Digest of Current Economic Statistics Belgium National Bank: Annual Report; Bulletin National Institute of Statistics: Bulletin of Statistics Canada Bank of Canada: Review Statistics Canada: Canadian Statistical Review France Bank of France: Statistiques Monetaires Definitives; Statistiques Monetaires Provisoires; Quarterly Bulletin National Institute of Statistics and Economic Research (n1sEE): Monthly Statistics Bulletin; Informations Rapides Ministry of Economics, Finance and Budget: Les Notes Bleues; Statistics and Financial Studies Germany Bundesbank: Monthly Report Federal Statistical Office: Aussenhande4 Reihe 1, Wirtschaft and Statutik Italy Bank of Italy: Annual Report; Bulletin Central Institute of Statistics: Monthly Bulletin Japan Bank of Japan: Economics Statistics Monthly Bureau of Statistics: Monthly Statistics of Japan Netherlands Netherlands Bank: Annual Report; Quarterly Bulletin Central Bureau of Statistics: Statistical Bulletin; Monthly Financial Statistics (Maandstatisteik Financiewezen);Sociale Maandstatisteik; Maandschrift (Monthly Bulletin) Spain Bank of Spain: Annual Report; Statistical Bulletin National Statistical Institute: Monthly Bulletin of Statistics; National Accounts of Spain Sweden Bank of Sweden: Yearbook; Quarterly Review National Institute of Economic Research: The Swedish Economy Central Bureau of Statistics: Monthly Digest of Swedish Statistics; Statistical Reports

INTERPRETATION

Switzerland
Swiss National Bank: Annual Report; The Swiss Banking System; Monthly Bulletin
	Message of the Federal Council to the Federal Assembly UK
Bank of England: Quarterly Bulletin
Office for National Statistics: Monthly Digest of Statistics; Economic Trends; Financial Statistics
USA
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System: Federal Reserve Bulletin
US Department of Commerce: Survey of Current Business US Treasury Department: Treasury Bulletin

Interpretation

These are the first questions to ask when you come across any economic indicators.

Who produced the figures? Was it a reliable government agency such as Statistics Canada or a recently established market research company?
Will the data be revised? If so by how much? For example, the American trade deficit figure of $18.8 billion for August 1996 was subsequently revised to $11.6 billion.
To what period do the figures relate? For example, American retail sales of $64 billion would be excellent for a month, appalling for a year.
Are the data seasonally adjusted? If so is the adjustment reliable? For example, an increase in sales of umbrellas in the wettest month on record will not necessarily indicate a lasting improvement in the fortunes of umbrella companies.
What were the start and end points for changes? For example, the change in unemployment between a recession and a boom will look much more impressive than the change between boom and slump.
What about inflation? For example, a 5% increase in spending is rather disappointing if prices rose by 10% over the same period.
What other yardsticks will aid interpretation? For example, total population, employment or GDP. A 5% rise in the number of jobs is not such good news if the working-age population expanded by 10% over the same period.

Chapter 2 runs through some critical ideas about numbers and their interpretation. Chapter 3 describes how economic activity is measured and comments on yardsticks and reliability. Chapters 4-13 cover the indicators themselves, as previewed above.
