EXCHANGE RATES

"Devaluation . . . would be a lunatic self-destroying operation,
Harold Wilson in 1963; in 1967 he devalued the pound.

Exchange rates are nothing more than the price of one currency in terms of another. They are determined mainly by supply and demand, which reflect trade and other international payments, and, much more important, volatile capital flows which are constantly shifting around the world in search of the best expected investment returns.

The prime indicator of market pressures on a currency is the figure for total currency flows in the balance of payments account (see Chapter 10). Other important influences are relative interest rates and yields (Chapter 12) and inflation (Chapter 13).

A history of exchange rates

The easiest way to understand exchange rates and their influence on the balance of payments is to review previous experiences.

The gold standard. Before 1914 exchange rates were fixed in terms of gold, trade was mainly in physical goods and capital flows were limited. A country which developed a deficit on its current account would first consume its reserves of foreign currencies. Then it would have to pay for the imports by shipping gold. 'tee transfer of gold would reduce the money supply in the deficit country and boost it elsewhere, since currencies were then backed by convertibility into gold.

	In the deficit country the contracting money supply would tend
to depress output and prices. Elsewhere the expanding money
supply would boost output and inflation. The deficit country
could then only afford to import a lower quantity of dearer fore the
goods. The surplus countries could import a higher quantity of d
deficit country's cheaper goods. Thus the current account

automatically return to equilibrium.

That was the theory. It seemed to work in practice until e

A HISTORY OF EXCHANGE RATES

System got out of balance in the 1920s. The gold standard was temporarily suspended during the first world war. Countries experienced rapid and varying rates of inflation and exports were grossly underpriced or overpriced when the gold standard was reintroduced at pre-war rates. Large current-account surpluses and deficits developed. The gold standard fell from favour and was abandoned almost universally by the early 1930s.

The 1930s. There were widespread experiments with fixed and floating exchange rates during the 1930s. Almost every country tried to alleviate the unemployment of the Depression by limiting imports and boosting exports with measures such as import duties,

quotas and exchange-rate devaluation or depreciation. It may seem obvious, but world exports cannot rise if world imports fall. The international payments system fell further into disrepute.

Adjustable pegs. An international conference was convened in America at Bretton Woods, New Hampshire, in June 1944. Participants agreed to form the IMF and World Bank to promote international monetary cooperation and the major currencies were fixed in relation to the dollar. Fluctuations were limited to 1 % in either direction, although larger revaluations and devaluations were

allowed with IMF permission. In addition, the American government agreed to buy gold on demand at just over $35 an ounce, which left only the dollar on a gold standard.

Floating rates. The Bretton Woods system broke down by the 1970s. Persistent American deficits had led to an international

excess of dollars and American gold reserves came under pressure. In August 1971 the Americans suspended the convertibility of the

dollar, imposed a 10% surcharge on imports and took other measures aimed at eliminating its balance of payments deficit. The major currencies were allowed to float, some within constraints posed by exchange controls (dirty floats).

Fixed rates with some flexibility were reintroduced in December

1971 following a meeting of the IMF Group of Ten at the Smith- Institute in Washington (the "Smithsonian agreement"). However, sterling was floated "temporarily" in June 1972 and by the following year all major currencies were floating or subject to maagerl floats. Despite bouts of extreme turbulence, most major currencies have remained floating ever since. The exceptions are EU currencies. Several of these spent the 1980s and most of the 1990s teed to one another in the exchange-rate mechanism of the European monetary system. At the start of 1999, eleven countries

fled their exchange rates irrevocably by joined a single European currency, the euro The auto floats freely against other currencies.






11 EXCHANGE RATES

NOMINAL EXCHANGE RATES

Measures:		Price of one currency in terms of another.
Significance:		Influences external trade, capital flows, and so on.
Presented as:		Units of one currency for one unit of another.
Focus on:		Trends.
Yardstick:		Annual movements of more than a few % in either

An exchange rate indicates how many units of one currency can be purchased with a single unit of another. For example, a rate of x'100 against the dollar indicates that one dollar buys 100 yen: $1 = Y100.

	direction can be destabilising.
Released: 		Minute-by-minute.

Jargon

Stronger and weaker. If the rate changes from $1 = Y100 to $1 _ x'200 the dollar has risen or strengthened by 100% against the yen (it will buy 100% more yen). The yen has fallen or weakened against the dollar, but not by 100% or it would be worthless. It has moved from X100 = $1 to x'100 = $0.50, a fall of 50%.

When currencies get stronger or weaker, they are said to have appreciated or depreciated if they are floating-rate currencies or to have been revalued or devalued if their rates are fixed by the central bank.

Spot rates. Rates for immediate settlement are spot rates.

Forward rates and futures. Exchange rates fixed today for settlement on a given future date reflect nothing more than spot exchange rates and interest rate differentials.

	For example, if a bank agrees to buy dollars in exchange for yen
	in one month, essentially it borrows the dollars today, converts
	them into yen, and places the yen in the money markets to earn
	interest for one month. At the end of the month the bank hands
	over the yen, takes the dollars, and uses them to repay the dollar
loan. Nobody takes an exchange-rate risk. 		and

Moreover, arbitrage ensures that forward rates, futures options move in line.

Forward exchange rates and futures should not therefore regarded as explicit indicators of expected exchange rates.

NOMINAL EXCHANGE RATES

What determines exchange rates

There is no neat explanation for what determines exchange rates. rj'he two main theories are based on purchasing power and asset markets (investment portfolios).

purchasing power parity (PPP). The traditional approach to exchange rates says that they move to keep international purchasing power in line (parity). If American inflation is 6% and Canadian inflation is 4%, the American dollar will fall by 2% to maintain pPP. With floating exchange rates this would happen automatically. If exchange rates are fixed, demand pressures will instead equalise inflation in the two countries.

Another version of this, favoured by some economists, is to define purchasing power parity as the exchange rate which equates the prices of a basket of goods and services in two countries. In the long term, it is argued, currencies should move towards their PPP. The Economist has a simpler approach with its Big Mac index.

BURGERNOMICS

The Economist's Big Mac index offers a guide to whether currencies are at their "correct" level. It is based on "purchasingpower parity" - the notion that an identical basket of goods and services should cost the same in all countries. The Big Mac pre is the exchange rate at which hamburgers would cost the same in America as abroad. The chart calculates the overor undervaluation of emerging-market currencies against the dollar. Dividing the local-currency price of a Big Mac in, say, Brazil, by its American price produces a dollar PPP of 1.2 reais. The actual dollar rate is 1.84 reais - ie, the currency is 34% undervalued. According to the Big Mac index, Russia, Turkey, China, Hungary and Malaysia have the cheapest currencies in the emerging world: they are all more than 50% undervalued compared with the dollar. At the other extreme, the Israeli shekel is 43% overvalued. The chart also shows that the euro is now fairly close to its Big Mac dollar pee, but sterling and the yen are both overvalued.

The Economist, January 8th 2000

143






11 EXCHANGE RATES

The Big Mac index
Local currency under(-)/over(+) valuation against the dollar, %
60 40 70-0*70 40 60

United States
Israel
Britain
Japan
Euro area
Argentina
UAE
Saudi Arabia
Chile
Taiwan
Colombia
Mexico
Indonesia
Greece
Singapore
Egypt
South Korea
Brazil
Czech Republic
Thailand
South Africa
Philippines
Poland
Hong Kong
Russia
Turkey
China
Hungary
Malaysia

i ima 2.44t
9t

3.50
3.
2.85
2.63

a.so
7.45
2.40
2.38
2.29
2.21
2.,1
7.05
2.03
1.94
1.91
1.78
,.s1
1.55
,.4B
1.47
,.3s
1.33
131
1.22
1211

,.zo

1.19

1.19

	-At martyr exchange rare pan an zaooJ.
Aolraq of fhkago. Naw York and San Fraxkco.

Sourte: The ftononslft using McDOnaltTS prke EaG.

Portfolio balance. The portfolio approach suggests that exchange rates move to balance total returns (interest plus expected exchangerate movements). If yen deposits pay 6% and dollar deposits Pay 8%, investors will buy dollars for the higher return until the exchange rate has been pushed up so far that the dollar is expected to depreciate by 2%. The expected return from the dollar will den exactly match the expected return from the yen.

Overshooting. The best guess is that exchange rates are determined by PPP in the long run, but that this is overridden in die short term by portfolio pressures. These tend to cause currencies to overshoot PPP equilibrium.

NOMINAL EXCHANGE RATES

Who determines exchange rates

Clearly there is a complex interaction between exchange rates and carious economic and financial variables, many of which are outside domestic control (they are determined exogenously). Central bas can either try to control these variables in order to fix their exchange rate, or leave the exchange rate to the markets.
	In fact, of the 150 or so main currencies in 1990, less than onefifth were freely floating, including those of Australia, Canada, Japan, Switzerland and America. Of the remaining currencies, 30 had managed floats or limited flexibility, while around 30 were pegged to the dollar, 14 to the French franc, five to other single currencies and 40 to the sDR (see page 146) or other baskets of currencies. By 1999, however, some 50 of the world's 180-odd currencies were freely floating.

Monetary policy. All economic policies affect exchange rates, although changes in interest rates have probably the most direct and visible influence. The exchange rate is thus the broadest indicator of monetary policy.

Intervention. Central banks frequently intervene in the currency markets. They buy or sell their currency in order to alter the balance of supply and demand and move the exchange rate. This is essentially a short-term smoothing activity since they can buy one currency only if they have another to sell. (See Reserves, page 137.)

Effects of exchange-rate movements

The most immediate effect of a weaker currency is higher domestic. inflation owing to dearer imports. At the same time, exports pced in foreign currencies and inflows of rents, interest, profits and dividends generate more income in domestic-currency terms. Thus the trade and current-account balances deteriorate.
	Later, after perhaps as much as 12-18 months, relative price movements cause a shift from imports to domestic production and exports. This boosts GDP and the trade and current accounts ~ prove. (Their deterioration followed by improvement is known
	the J-curve effect.) However, higher inflation caused by a weaker currency can wipe out any current account improvement within number of years.

	pital account. With regard to the capital account of the bal
	1k More payments, a weaker currency makes inward investment
411d		attractive. In foreign-currency terms outlays are lower
	returns are higher, but this may not be enough to attract

145
11 EXCHANGE RATES

investors if the currency weakened because of unfavourable domestic economic conditions.

Table 11.1 Exchange rates Currency units per $, period average

Country			Currency	1980	1985	1990	1995 I9gg
Australia			dollar	0.88	1.43	1.28	1.35 1.59
Austria			schilling	12.94	20.69	11.37	10.08 12.38
Belgium			franc	29.25	59.43	33.42	29.50 36.30
Canada			dollar	1.17	1.37	1.17	1.37 1.48
Denmark			krone	5.64	10.59	6.19	5.60 6.70
France			franc	4.23	8.98	5.45	4.99 5,90
Germany			D-mark	1.82	2.94	1.62	1.43 1.76
Italy		lira		831.00	1,909.00	1,198.00	1,629.00 1,736.00
Japan		yen		226.70	238.60	144.80	94.10 130.90
Netherland			guilder	1.99	3.32	1.82	1.61 1.99
Spain		peseta		71.70	170.10	101.90	124.70 149.40
Sweden			krona	4.23	8.60	5.92	7.13 7.95
Switzerland			franc	1.68	2.46	1.39	1.18 1.45
UK		pound		0.43	0.78	0.56	0.63 0.60
USA		dollar		1.00	1.00	1.00	1.00 1.00
SDR			0.78		0.99	0.74	0.69 0.74
ECU			1.31		1.32	0.79	0.77 0.89

Source: IMF.

SPECIAL DRAWING RIGHTS (SDR)

Measures:		The value of a basket of four major currencies, see
	Table 11.2.
Significance:		Stable international currency and reserves asset
Presented as:		Absolute value per unit of currency.
Focus on:		Market rate against any currency
Yardstick:
Released:

Overview

Average: SDR I = $1.19 for I 980-90 and $1.52 for 1995. Several times daily.

The SDR (special drawing right) has some of the characteristics  a world currency. It was introduced by the IMF in 1970 to boost world liquidity after the ratio of world reserves to imports had > ~' en by half since the 1950s. Through book-keeping entries) the Fund allocated sDRS to member countries in proportion to quotas (see below). Countries in need of foreign currency obtain them from other central banks in exchange for sDRS.

SPECIAL DRAWING RIGHTS

Advantages

	. The sDR is stable. It is used for accounting purposes by the 1tvtF and even some multinational corporations. Commercial bas accept deposits and make loans in sDRS, and it is used to price some international transactions.

Disadvantages. Since the sDR is an average of five currencies it is less valuable than the strongest and is among the first to go when reserves are sold off. Developing countries argue that it would help their liquidity if they had more sDRS, but the quota system ensures that the rich industrial countries have most of them.

Value

sDlts were first allocated in 1970 equal to 1/3s of an ounce of gold, or exactly $1 ($1.0857 after the dollar was devalued in 1971). When the dollar came off the gold standard the sDR was fixed from 1974 in terms of a basket of 16 currencies. This proved too unwieldy and in 1981 the basket was slimmed to five major currencies with weights broadly reflecting their importance in international trade. With the creation of the euro in 1999, the number of currencies was reduced to four (see Table 11.2).
	Since 1981 the Ih1F has paid the full market rate of interest on the sDR, based on a weighted average of rates paid by the individual constituents.

Table 11.2 Currencies in the SDR

Country Currency					1986-90	1991-95	1996-98 	1999-
USA			dollar
Germany			D-mark
Japan			yen
France			franc
	pound
Eurozone			euro

Source: IMF.

42 19 15 12 11

40 21 17 11 11

39		39
21
18
11
11

Quotas

'l'he IMF allocates to each member country a quota which reflects the ""'try's importance in world trade and payments. The size of the quota determines voting powers, subscriptions in gold and eurrencies, borrowing powers and sDR allocations.
'441Y member with balance of payments difficulties may swap its
11 EXCHANGE RATES

SDRS for reserve currencies at IH1F-designated central banks, It c~ also use its own currency to buy (draw) foreign currency from the Fund's pool. The first chunk of currencies (the reserve tranche), amounting to 25% of the member's quota, may be taken uncondi_ tionally. Four additional credit tranches each worth another 25% of the quota may be taken under progressively tougher terms and conditions. When these options are used up there are other borrowing facilities available. The uAF also arranges standby credits in times of severe strain on a currency.

Table 11.3 SDR exchange rates
Currency units per SDR, period average

Country			Currency		1980	1985	1990	1995	1998
Australia			dollar		1.52	1.54	1.65	2.05	2.29
Austria			schilling		17.61	18.98	15.19	15.29	16.54
Belgium			franc	40.21		55.32	44.08	44.75	48.68
Canada			dollar		1.52	1.54	1.65	2.08	2.16
Denmark			krone	7.67		9.85	8.22	8.50	8.99
France			franc	4.90		5.95	5.17	7.57	7.92
Germany			D-mark		2.50	2.70	2.13	2.17	2.36
Italy		lira1,186.80 1,843.70 1,607.80 2,471.11 2,327.60
Japan			yen		258.91	220.23	191.21	142.75	162.77
Netherland			guilder		2.72	3.05	2.40	2.44	2.66
Spain			peseta		101.08	169.32	137.87	189.16	200.79
Sweden			krona		5.58	8.37	8.11	10.82	11.35
Switzerland			franc		2.25	2.28	1.84	1.79	1.94
UK		pound			0.54	0.76	0.74	0.96	0.85
USA		dollar			1.28	1.10	1.42	1.52	1.36

Source: IMF.

Figure 11.1

Changes in exchange rates change, national currency units per SDR, 1990-98

148

EMU, ECU, ERM AND EURO

EMLJ, ECU, ERM AND EURO

Measures:		The euro became the single currency of I I Eu countries
	on January I st 1999.
	Reserve asset, international currency and basis of the
	remains of the European exchange-rate mechanism. Not
	yet in circulation in the form of notes and coin.
	Euros per dollar, yen per euro; (British) pence per euro.
	Rate against other currencies, especially the dollar.
	The euro began life at around  I .17 to the dollar. By late
	1999 it was trading at just over  I .
Released:		Continuously.

Significance:

Presented as:

Focus on: Yardstick:

Overview

A timetable and criteria for the creation of a single currency as part of economic and monetary union (Emu) was agreed by the Eu
at Maastricht in 1991. The programme built on the exchange rate mechanism (Eltlvl) and the European currency unit (ecu).

The ecu

Introduced on March 13th 1979, the ecu superseded the European unit of account (EUA). While the EuA was no more than a common unit for book-keeping purposes, the ecu was a reserve

asset and a currency in its own right used for commercial transactions and bond issues.

Table 11.4 Ecu exchange rates
Currency units per ecu, period average

Country							Currency	1980	1985	1990	1995	1998
Australia							dollar
Austria							schilling
Belgium		franc
Canada			dollar
Denmark		krone
France			franc
		any		D-mark
	y			lira
Japes
Netherland		yen
Spain			guilder
Sweden		peseta
			krona
~tzerland		franc
USA			Pound
Source			dollar

s: I1KF. European Commission.

	1.22					1.09	1.63	1.76	1.86
	21.62					18.02	15.79	13.18	14.44
	40.60					44.91	42.25	38.56	42.35
	1.63					1.04	1.49	1.80	1.73
	7.83					8.02	7.86	7.32	7.81
	5.87					6.80	6.91	6.52	6.88
	2.52					2.23	2.05	1.87	2.05
	1,189.00					1,448.00	1,522.00	2,129.00	2,025.56
	315.04					180.56	183.66	122.99	152.73
	2.76					2.51	2.31	2.10	2.32
	99.70					129.10	129.40	162.98	174.32
	5.89					6.56	7.54	9.32	9.27
	2.33					1.88	1.77	1.55	1.69
	0.60					0.59	0.71	0.83	0.70
	1.39					0.76	1.27	1.31	1.17

149
11 EXCHANGE RATES

	The ecu was based on a basket of EC currencies weight according to the relative size of GDP arid trade volume.

The ERM

Before the creation of the euro, the ERM linked most of the EU,s national currencies, including all those who adopted the single currency. Britain and Italy withdrew in September 1992. The Italians later rejoined.
	Each ERM currency had a fixed central rate against the eeU. From these rates a "parity grid" of cross-rates between each Pair of currencies was calculated. In most countries, central banks were required to keep their own currencies within 2.25% of all other cross-parities. For some countries, however, the limit was 6%, and was raised to 15% after the near-collapse of the ERri in mid-1993.
	When the euro was created on January 1 st 1999, the Eltlvt was superseded by a new arrangement, ERM2. Countries that want to join the euro are expected to be members of ERM2 before acceding. At present, two of the four Eu countries that are not members of the euro, Denmark and Greece, are members of E1tM2. The British pound and Swedish krona float freely against other currencies.
	In ERM2, central rates are defined against the euro, rather than the ecu, and the maximum divergence permitted from the crossparities is 15%. However, the Danes have negotiated a narrower band of 2.25%.

The euro
The December 1995 Eu summit in Madrid confirmed the intention to introduce a single European currency, to be known as the euro, on January 1 st 1999.
	The summit adopted changeover recommendations presented in a 1995 European Commission Green Paper and a report by the European Monetary Institute (the forerunner of the European Central Bank). On the basis of economic and financial indicators of "convergence" (including budget deficits, ratios of debt to GDP, interest rates and inflation rates), initial participants were selected in early 1998. Eleven countries that wanted to join were deemed to have qualified. Britain and Denmark decided to opt out. Greece and Sweden were deemed not to have qualified.
On January 1 st 1999 the exchange rates of the 11 countries
were irrevocably fixed. The euro replaced the ecu at a rate of
one to one. On January 1st 2002 euro notes and coins are due ebe
be introduced. National currency notes and coins are due
withdrawn from circulation six months later.

150

EMU, ECU, ERM AND EURO

	Official interest rates in the 11 Eurozone countries are now set by the European Central Bank. The governors of the national central banks and six others sit on the EcB's rate-setting governing council.

Table 11.5 Permanent conversion rates against Eurozone currencies, December 31st 1998

Country		Currency
	lE _

Austria			Sch	13.7603
Belgiuxn/Luxembourg			BFrlL,Fr	40.3399
Finland			FM	5.94573
France			FFr	6.55957
Germany			DM	1.95583
Ireland			IC	0.787564
Italy			L	1936.27
Netherlands			Fl	2.20371
Portugal			Es	200.482
Spain			Pta	166.386

Euro value against leading currencies, Dec 31st 1998
us
Japan UK Switzerland

Source: Financial Times.

	1.1743
132.4554
0.7058
1.6129

EFFECTIVE EXCHANGE RATES

Measures: Average exchange rate against a basket of currencies. Significance: Shows overall exchange-rate movements. Presented as: Index numbers.
Focus on:		Trends.
Yardstick:		An increase indicates a strengthening currency. Movements
	of more than a few percentage points a year can be
	destabilising.
	Daily.
Overview

~ effective exchange rate (EER) measures the overall value of one at'rrency against a basket of other currencies. Changes indicate the

age change in one currency relative to all the others.
	Effective exchange rates are weighted averages of many curren~' movements with weights chosen to reflect the relative importance of each currency in the home country's trade. For example,

Released:
11 EXCHANGE RATES

if the dollar appreciates by 10% against the Japanese yen but is unchanged against all other currencies, and if the yen accounts for 25% of American trade, the dollar's effective exchange rate ba risen by 2.5%.
	For obvious reasons EERs are sometimes known as trade-weighted exchange rates. There are many ways of selecting the weigh based on imports of manufactured goods, total trade, and so on.

MERMs. Most indices use weights from the IMF's multilateral exchange-rate model (MERM). This tries to measure the effect of exchange-rate changes on prices of exports and imports, and the response of trade flows to such price changes.

Main sources. The ImF, the major central banks and some other organisations calculate effective rates for all the major currencies. The Bank of England indices published in The Economist and some daily newspapers are based on the IN1F's model. Most EElts are presented in index form, although sometimes they are shown as the percentage change since a chosen base date.

Interpretation

If, for example, the effective exchange rate for the dollar rises by 1%, this indicates that the various exchange-rate changes that have taken place are the same as a flat 1% rise in the dollar against every individual currency. In other words, the observed movements will have the same effect on the American trade balance as a 1 % overall rise in the dollar.
	Effective exchange rates do not take account of inflation so they do not reveal anything about changes in a country's competitiveness (see Real exchange rates below).

152

EFFECTIVE EXCHANGE RATES

Tabje 11.6 Effective exchange rates dual averages; 1995=100

country

Au
Austria

Belgium
Canada
Denmark
France
Germany
Italy
Japan
Netherland
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland

UK
USA

Figure 11.2

Source: DECD.

1990							1993	1994	1995	1996	1997	1998

	106.4							95.0	103.1	100.0	109.2	110.2	101.9
	87.6							92.6	95.2	100.0	99.0	97.0	98.9
	84.7							90.1	94.3	100.0	98.3	94.3	96.2
	112.7							104.7	100.4	100.0	102.1	102.6	98.2
	86.4							92.4	95.0	100.0	99.1	96.6	99.2
	85.9							92.2	95.6	100.3	100.3	97.2	99.8
	78.7							87.6	92.5	100.0	98.6	95.1	98.6
	122.7							105.9	107.2	100.0	110.1	111.1	114.1
	53.0							79.4	93.3	100.0	87.2	83.2	86.0
	83.6							90.7	94.2	100.0	98.5	93.8	96.5
	115.9							103.3	99.2	100.0	101.1	96.9	98.2
	115.1							97.4	99.3	100.0	110.1	106.4	106.1
	81.5							84.0	92.3	100.0	98.6	92.9	96.5
	108.9							100.0	103.3	100.0	102.2	118.9	126.8
	82.8							91.5	97.7	100.0	105.4	112.9	125.1

Changes in effective exchange rates
% change, 19998

to
62.3
60-
51.1

,o

30						25.3
70						,8.4	76.4	16.2	15.4

10-

0

-10

-2p

14.8			13.6	12.9

-4.2				_7.0	-7.8
			-17.9_75.3

											5P ~~	,E	e	a	~t-	,~ a	a	c	a	c
J fiat		J ..(sov tac .Soar w9~ W ~daW`'aW .~a , caa'~

1MF.

153
11 EXCHANGE RATES

REAL EXCHANGE RATES; COMPETITIVENESS

Measures:		International competitiveness.
Significance:		Indicative of a country's ability to sell abroad and of
	price (inflation and exchange rate) pressures on
	balance of payments.
Presented as:		Index numbers.
Focus on:		Trends.
Yardstick:		The lower the index, the more competitive the country;
Released:		Monthly, one month in arrears.

The international competitiveness of goods and services produced in a country depends on relative movements in costs or prices after adjusting for exchange-rate movements. For example, if prices increase by 4% in Germany and 6% in America, American competitiveness appears to have fallen by 2%. However, if over the same period the dollar fell by 3%, overall American competitiveness has actually improved by 1%. Such measures of overall competitiveness are known as "relative costs or prices expressed in a common currency" or, more simply, real exchange rates.

Indicators of prices and costs

There is no ideal measure of competitiveness. Those in common use are listed below. They are described in terms of America, but the calculations are the same for any country.

Relative export prices. American export prices divided by a weighted average of competitors' export prices, all expressed in a common currency. This might seem to be a logical basis for assessing price competitiveness but there are several drawbacks. Such an exchange rate covers only goods that are traded; it does not take account of competition between imports and domestic production in home or overseas markets; it measures orders but ignores unsuccessful quotations; and it fails to take account of profitability (exporters in general are price-takers; they may be forced to absorb exchange-rate movements in profits).

Relative export profitability. American export prices divided by American producer prices. This is not a measure of internanll8l competitiveness, but it is a useful supplement to relative export prices. It indicates the extent to which changes in export pncO reflect changes in the profit margins on exports against how sales. 1f export prices rise less rapidly than domestic prices, e
profitability has declined.

REAL EXCHANGE RATES; COMPETITIVENESS

import price competitiveness. American producer prices divided by American import prices. This provides a guide to import competitiveness, but again it ignores relative profitability.

Relative producer prices. American producer prices divided by a weighted average of competitors producer prices. This compares home prices with prices that they will be competing against overseas. It tends to overemphasise domestic markets.

Relative consumer prices. American consumer prices divided by a weighted average of competitors' consumer prices. This ignores capital and intermediate goods, but it is good for comparing relative consumer purchasing power.

Relative GDP value-added deflators. The American GDP deflator divided by a weighted average of competitors' GDP deflators. This is the most comprehensive basis for comparison, covering unit labour costs and profits per unit of output. One drawback is that some of the items in GDP are not traded, although it might be argued that inflation pressures are ultimately transmitted uniformly through all goods and services. Another problem is that the deflators are available only after a sizeable lag.

Relative unit labour costs. An alternative to price competitiveness is to look at cost competitiveness. This has the advantage of covering all industries: exporters, potential exporters and those competing with imports. However, because of a lack of data the only sensible indicator is relative unit labour costs (say, American

Table 11.7 Real effective exchange rates
Relative normalised unit labour costs, period averages, 1995=100

Country Currency 1992						1993	1994	1995	1996	1997

Australia								dollar	105.3	98.6	102.4	100.0	110.0	109.5
Austria								schilling	104.9	105.5	103.4	100.0	35.5	91.0
Belgium								franc	91.4	93.4	95.5	100.0	97.6	93.4
Canada								dollar	119.2	108.9	100.7	100.0	102.1	102.8
Denmark								krone	97.9	99.0	97.6	100.0	97.3	95.0
France								franc	98.0	100.1	99.7	100.0	97.2	93.3
~~anY								D-mark	85.6	91.0	93.4	100.0	98.0	91.1
Japan								lira	137.0	115.0	107.9	100.0	111.7	114.9
Netherland								yen	73.8	89.6	95.8	100.0	84.6	79.5
Spain								guilder	97.2	98.5	98.3	100.0	96.3	90.6
Sweden								Peseta	117.0	108.1	101.3	100.0	103.0	101.2
	Switzerland bona							137.5	104.8	101.7	100.0	110.4	104.5
	franc							85.8	86.7	94.2	100.0	99.5	95.3
[1SA								pound	114.1	106.1	106.0	100.0	103.4	125.5

r_
dollar 105.1						107.9	106.4	100.0	105.8	114.8
11 EXCHANGE RATES

Figure 11.3

Changes in real effective exchange
change, 1992-97

zo

11> >o.o
10				9.7	7.7	6.4
4.0		7.7

0
F1 n F] F-1

.io

_p

-30

S~ye				,-		~ c	PJ -	0e . O c	,~.-~ a.

Source: IMF.

-3.0

m.cs divided by a weighted average of competitors' m.cs, all in a common currency). This excludes profits and prices of materials.

Normalised relative unit labour costs. These are relative unit labour costs adjusted to allow for short-term deviations in productivity from long-term trends. This smooths out differences in the cyclical position of the countries being compared, but because of the difficulties of adjusting productivity for the cycle it should be treated with care.

Interpretation

Common practice. Relative unit labour costs in manufacturing and relative export prices are the most popular measures, Partly because they are available quickly and easily. However, rather than relying on just one indicator it is a good idea to look at several to get a feel for "average" changes.
	The indicators are expressed in index form. The index rises domestic costs or prices increase faster than foreign costs or prices Thus a larger index number (stronger real exchange rate) indicates that the home country is less competitive. The broad implication Is that to restore competitiveness, the currency must weaken or domestic prices/costs will have to increase less than foreign prices/costs.
	Current international practice uses 1995 as a base for indO numbers.
	The indices do not take account of non-price factors (product differentiation) such as quality, reliability and design.

156

TERMS OF TRADE

,rEFMS OF TRADE

Measures: Significance:

Presented as: Focus on: Yardstick:

	The ratio of export prices to import prices.
	Measures the volume of imports that can be bought with
	one unit of exports.
	Index numbers.
	Changes in the index.
	An improvement indicates that export earnings will buy
	more imports - but the trade balance may worsen.
Released:		Monthly.

Overview

fbe terms of trade indicate the purchasing power of a country's exports in terms of the imports that they will buy.

Favourable or unfavourable. The terms of trade are said to improve if export prices rise more rapidly or fall more slowly than import prices. For example, if export prices rise by 5% and import prices rise by 2%, a given volume of exports buys roughly 3% more imports; the terms of trade have improved by 3%.
	Common terminology suggests that movements in the terms of trade are "favourable" or "unfavourable". However, after an "unfavourable" movement in the terms of trade, the trade balance will tend to improve (the smaller rise in export prices than import prices means that exports are more competitive), while a "favourable" movement in the terms of trade may price exporters out of the market and result in a weaker trade balance (see Trade balance and Exchange rates, pages 130 and 140).

Which way is up? Governments usually define the terms of trade as export prices divided by import prices expressed in index form. A rise in the index indicates an improvement in the terms of trade
one unit of exports will buy more imports. Academics sometimes do it the other way around, as import prices divided by export Prices. The lower the number, the fewer exports needed to obtain One unit of imports. The message is the same in both cases, but You need to check the basis for the calculation before you can interpret the numbers.

U11it value or average values. Terms of trade indices constructed using import and export unit value indices (see Export and oPrt Prices, page 196) are not affected by changes in the combasdity breakdown of imports or exports. Terms of trade indices based n average value indices reflect changes in composition as well as changes in prices.

157
TERMS pg		c

	In general unit values are most commonly used and are a safactory basis for the terms of trade, but where there has been. structural shift in the composition of trade average value indicator, are better. For example, if a country imported a larger proportioQ of oil in 1980 than in 1990 and if oil prices rise, a unit value terra of trade indicator based on 1980 weights will overstate deterioration in the terms of trade. An average value indicator WA show a smaller, more realistic, deterioration.

Devaluation or depreciation. Typically, an exchange-rate devaluation or depreciation increases import prices relative to export prices and causes the terms of trade to deteriorate.

12

MONEY AND FINANCIAL
MARKETS

"There have been three great inventions since the beginning of time:
fire, the wheel and central banking."
Will Rogers

Money

The cornerstone of the modern economy is money, which is a measure of value, a medium of exchange and a store of wealth. It is also the bridge between real and nominal magnitudes, so understanding it is vital for understanding and controlling inflation.

Markets

Financial markets bring together the supply of savings and the

demand for money to finance businesses and consumer spending. The markets also allow people to complete commercial

transactions and spread risks. Note that there are two sides to every transaction: for every lender there is a borrower; for every seller, a buyer.

Interest rates

Interest rates are the price of money. They link large stocks of
physical and financial assets with smaller flows of savings and investment; they connect the present and the future; and they are sensitive to inflation expectations. As a result they are very volatile and hard to predict. With all these factors at work, it is hardly surprising that there is no simple theory which explains Why interest rates behave as they do.

Liberalisation and globalisation

Financial systems changed dramatically in the 1970s and 1980s. There were three main influences.

~ioeralisa '

and deregulation. Exch
Lion		ange, credit and
