2 ESSENTIAL MECHANICS

figures would show that sales fell in January only because this was a correction to an exceptionally steep rise in the earlier few months.

Table 2.7 Analysing seasonal and erratic influences

					3-month
Retail				% change over	moving average
sales			1	1 month	12	% change from

index		month annualised months	Index 12 months ago

	A		B		C	D	E	F
1997
Oct			119.2
Nov			120.2	0.8
Dec			121.8	1.3			120.4
1998
Jan			121.6	-0.2			121.2
Oct			130.7	-0.5	-5.8	9.6
Nov			133.4	2.1	27.8	11.0
Dec			134.4	0.7	9.3	10.3	132.8	10.3
1999
Jan			129.2	-3.9	-37.7	6.2	132.3	9.2~

Note: Calculations for January 1999:
Column B: [(129.2 = 134.4) - I] X 100 = -3.9%
Column C: [(129.2 = 134.4)1Z - lj x 100 = -37.7%
Column D: [(129.2 = 121.6) - 1] X 100 = 6.2%
Column E: (133.4 + 134.4 + 129.2) = 3 = 132.3
Column F: [(132.3 = 121.2) - I] x 100 = 9.2%

Commentators are inclined to interpret blips as changes in trend. In general you should examine a run of data, form a view about the trend, and stick to it until there is clear evidence that the trend has changed.

24

MEASURING ECONOMIC
ACTIVITY

"GDP should really stand for grossly deceptive product."
The Economist

Total economic activity may be measured in three different but equivalent ways.

Perhaps the most obvious approach is to add up the value of all goods and services produced in a given period of time, such as one year. Money values may be imputed for services such as health care which do not change hands for cash. Since the output of one business (for example, steel) can be the input of another (for example, automobiles), double counting is avoided by combining only "value added", which for any one activity is the total value of production less the cost of inputs such as raw materials and components valued elsewhere.

A second approach is to add up the expenditure which takes place when the output is sold. Since al] spending is received as incomes, a third alternative is to value producers' incomes.

Thus output = expenditure = incomes.

The precise definition of economic activity varies. The three main concepts are gross domestic product, gross national product and net national product.

Gross domestic product. GDP is the total of all economic activity in one country, regardless of who owns the productive assets. For example, Britain's GDP includes the profits of a foreign firm located in Britain even if they A remitted to the firm's parent company in another country.

Gross national income or gross national product. cNI, a term which has replaced GNP in national accounts, is the total of incomes earned by residents of a country, regardless of where the assets are located. For example, Britain's GNI includes profits from British-owned businesses located in other countries.

Net national income. The "gross" in GDP and GNI indicates that

25







3 MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY

there is no allowance for depreciation (capital consumption)

amount of capital resources used up in the production process due to wear and tear, accidental damage, obsolescence or retirement of capital assets. Net national income is GNI less depreciation.

The relationship between the three measures is straightforward:

GDP (gross domestic product)
+ net property income from abroad (rent, interest, profits and
dividends)
= GNI (gross national income)
- capital consumption (depreciation)
= NM (net national income)

Capital consumption. Capital consumption is not identifiable from a set of transactions; it can only be imputed by a system of conventions. For example, when investment spending of $lm on a new machine is included in GDP figures, national accounts statisticians pencil in depreciation of, say, $100,000 a year for each of the next ten years. This gives a stinted view of productive capacity. After five years the machine might still be producing at full capacity, but the national accounts would show it as capable of producing only half the volume that it could when new.

Choosing between GDP, GNI and NNI

Net national income (NNI) is the most comprehensive measure of economic activity, but it is of little practical value due to the problems of accounting for depreciation. Gross concepts are more useful.
	All the major industrial countries now use GDP as their main measure of national economic activity. America, Germany and Japan, which had until the early 1990s focused on GNP, now use GDP. The difference between GDP and GNI or GNP is usually relatively small, perhaps 1% of GDP, but there are a few exceptions; for example, in 1997 Ireland's GDP was 15% bigger than its GNI, owing to the profits earned by foreign investors in the country. In the short term a large change in total net property income has only a minor effect on GDP. When reviewing longerterm trends, it is advisable to check net property income to seep if it is making GNI grow faster than GDP.

Net material product

Some countries, mainly centrally planned economies, use or have used net material product (NMP) to measure overall

26

OMISSIONS

economic activity. This has been supplanted by GDP in the former communist countries as they have adopted market economies. NMr is less comprehensive than GDP because it excludes "non-productive services", such as banking, government administration, health and education, and is quoted net of capital consumption (depreciation). As a rule of thumb, NMP is roughly 80-90% of GDP.

Did the American economy start to recover in the second quarter of this year [1991], or was it stuck in recession? America's real gross national product (GNP, the measure that is watched by the government and Wall Street and splashed across newspaper headlines, fell by 0.1% at an annual rate in the second quarter. However, gross domestic product (GDP) rose by 0.8% at an annual rate. By coincidence, the Department of Commerce has just decided that from November [1991], when the third-quarter figures will be released, it will concentrate more on GDP than on GNP.
	Cynics might claim that the switch to GDP is a bid to fiddle the figures. In fact it is America's first step to bring its national accounts into line with most of the rest of the world.
	GNP is probably more useful in comparing the relative levels of income per head in different countries, but GDP provides a better guide to changes in domestic production and hence is the better tool for steering economic policy. Because net income from abroad tends to be volatile, the two measures can often move in completely different directions from one quarter to another. Over longer periods, however, the two measures usually fall into step. Indeed, since the third quarter of last year [1990], America's GDP and GNP have both fallen by exactly the same amount. The government cannot boost its flagging growth rate simply by revising its figures; that requires a revision of its policies.
The Economist, September 21st 1991

EMISSIONS

Deliberate omissions

There are many things which are not in GDP, including the following.

Transfer payments. For example, social security and pensions.
Gifts. For example, $10 from Aunt Agatha on your birthday.
Unpaid and domestic activities. If you cut your grass or
3 MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY

paint your house the value of this productive activity is not recorded in GDP, but it is if you pay someone to do it for you.
Barter transactions. For example, the exchange of a sack of wheat for a can of petrol.
Second-hand transactions. For example, the sale of a used car (where the production was recorded in an earlier year).
Intermediate transactions. For example, a lump of metal may be sold several times, perhaps as ore, pig iron, part of a component and, finally, part of a washing machine (the metal is included in GDP once at the net total of the value added between the initial production of the ore and its final sale as a finished item).
Leisure. An improved production process which creates the same output but gives more recreational time is recorded in the national accounts at exactly the same value as the old process.
Depletion of resources. For example, oil production is recorded at sale price minus production costs and no allowance is made for the fact that an irreplaceable part of the nation's capital stock of resources has been consumed.
Environmental costs. GDP figures do not distinguish between green and polluting industries.
Allowance for non-profit making and inefficient activities. The civil service and police force are valued according to expenditure on salaries, equipment, and so on (the appropriate price for these services might be judged to be very different if they were provided by private companies).
Allowance for changes in quality. You can buy very different electronic goods for the same inflation-adjusted outlay as a few years ago, but GDP data do not take account of such technological improvements.

Some of the exclusions can be identified elsewhere. For example, environmental costs are seen in statistics on pollution and most countries report known oil or coal reserves (although these estimates may be over-optimistic or clouded by genuine ignorance . about the size of underground reserves).
	One other point to note is that the more advanced government statistical agencies include in GDP an allowance for the imputed rent paid by home owner-occupiers. This avoids an apparent change in national output because of any switch between owneroccupation and renting.

Surveys and sampling

Many of the figures which go into GDP are collected by surveys; For example, governments ask selected manufacturing or retail-:

28

OUTPUT, EXPENDITURE AND INCOME

ing companies for details of their output or sales each month. This information is used to make inferences about all manufacturers or all retailers. Such estimates may not be correct, especially as the most dynamic parts of the economy are small firms constantly coming into and going out of existence, which may never be surveyed.
	Sample evidence is supplemented by other information, including documentation required initially for bureaucratic purposes such as customs clearance or tax assessment. Such data take a long time to collect and analyse, which is why economic figures are frequently revised even when they are several years old.

Unrecorded transactions

GDP may under-record economic activity, not least because of the difficulties of keeping track of new small businesses and because of tax avoidance or evasion.
	Deliberately concealed transactions form the black, hidden or shadow economy. This is largest at times when, and in countries where, taxes are high and bureaucracy is smothering. Estimates of the size of the shadow economy vary enormously. For example, differing studies put America's at 4-33%, Germany's at 3-28% and Britain's at 2-15%. What is agreed, though, is that among the industrial countries the black economy is largest in Italy, at perhaps one-third of GDP, followed by Spain, Belgium and Sweden, while the smallest black economies are in Japan and Switzerland at around 4% of GDP.
	The only industrial countries that adjust their GDP figures for the shadow economy are Italy and America and they may well underestimate its size.

OUTPUT, EXPENDITURE AND INCOME

Output

The output measure of GDP is obtained by combining value added (value of production less cost of inputs) by all businesses: agriculture, mining, manufacturing and services. Output data are usually presented in index form (that is, with a base year such as 1995 equal to 100).

Sectors. In general countries have larger agricultural sectors in the ear1Y stages of economic development (for example, sub-Saharan Africa, see Figure 3.1). The manufacturing sector's share of output increases as the economy develops (Asia-Pacific) and services take
30

3 MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY

Figure 3.1

GDP per sector
% of total GDP, 1997

	DECD		Developing World
average countries

Agriculture Other industry manufacturing Services

the largest share of output in mature economies (America).
	Highly detailed data are often available. The production of tens or hundreds of goods and services industries may be recorded separately. For example, there will probably be an appropriate index in the GDP output breakdown to allow you to compare the ` performance of, say, a furniture manufacturing company with
that of the industry as a whole. The industrialised countries gen- 3 erally publish more detailed (and more up-to-date) statistics than
less developed countries.

Classifications. Economic information has to be categorised, but the correct classification is not always self-evident. For example, should the production of man-made fibres from petroleum be recorded under textiles (as they generally used to be) or chemicals (as they are now)?
	Standards have been introduced to deal with these problems and provide consistency. Industrial production, retail trade, imports and exports are classified according to standard themes. Many countries now follow the United Nations' international standard industrial classification (ISIC), while European countries tend to use the similar Eu Nomenclature generale des activites dans les Communautes Europeennes (NACE). These are fairly detailed and they need revision from time to time. ,
	For example, if the standard industrial classification (SIC)', introduced in the UK in 1948 had not been revised several^; times, computer manufacturing would be classified under office'' equipment, which is part of non-electrical engineering.

OUTPUT, EXPENDITURE AND INCOME

	When making sectoral comparisons between two or more countries, try to find out if the sectors are made up of the same industries, otherwise there may be inconsistencies in the comparison.

Expenditure

The expenditure measure of GDP is obtained by adding up all spending:

consumption (spending on items such as food and clothing) + investment (spending on houses, factories, and so on) = total domestic expenditure + exports of goods and services (foreigners' spending) = total final expenditure - imports of goods and services (spending abroad) ` = GDP

Government consumption. The level of government spending reflects the role of the state. Government consumption is generally 10-20% of GDP, although it is higher in countries such as Denmark and Sweden where the state provides many services. Changes in government spending tend to reflect political decisions rather than market forces.

Private consumption. This is also called personal consumption or consumer expenditure. It is generally the largest individual category of spending (but see exports, below). In the industrialised countries consumption is around 60% of GDP. The ratio is much higher in poor countries which invest less and consume more.

Investment. Investment is perhaps the key structural component of spending since it lays down the basis for future production. It covers spending on factories, machinery, equipment, dwellings and inventories of raw materials and other items. Investment averages about 20% of GDP in the industrialised countries, but is nearer 30% of GDP in East Asian countries (see Figure 3.2).

Consumption or investment? There are some anomalies in the identification of consumption and investment. Government spending on roads, defence and education is generally scored as consumption rather than investment. Consumer spending on cars and other durable goods (items with a life of over one year) is considered to be consumption. Capital goods purchased by a financial institution and leased to an industrial company are also usually classified as consumption. Thus consumption tends to be overstated and investment under-recorded.
3 MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY

Figure 3.2

Domestic spending
/a of GDP, 1997

Source: World Bank.

Investment

Government consumption

Private consumption

Total domestic expenditure (TDE). Consumption plus investment is known as total domestic expenditure. This is a useful concept because it measures domestic spending, some of which goes on imported goods and services. It under-records sales because it does not include those goods and services sold abroad (exports).

Total final expenditure/output (TFE/TFO). Consumption and investment plus exports of goods and services is known as total final expenditure. This takes account of the fact that some consumer and investment goods and services are purchased by foreigners.
	Another way of looking at this is as total final output: the value of home-produced and imported goods and services available for consumption, investment or export.
	TFE and TFO are identical in coverage. The difference is in the terminology, which depends on whether the emphasis is on output or spending. Since some expenditure goes on goods and services originating overseas, TFE/TPO has to be reduced by the amount of imports of goods and services to give total output.

Exports and imports. Exports generate foreign currency income, while imports are a leakage of domestic spending into another country's production. These external transactions can have an important effect on GDP.
	Some countries have a low dependence on external trade. American imports and exports are each about 10/D of GDP. Other countries, especially those on the Pacific rim, are heavily depen-

32

OUTPUT, EXPENDITURE AND INCOME

Figure 3.3

Trade in goods and services
% of GDP, 1997

Germany				DECD	World	Developing
	average			countries

Exports

Imports

dent on external flows. Hong Kong and Singapore, both trading economies, have imports and exports each of which are 100-200% of GDP (many imports are re-exported). These are open economies, while America and Japan are relatively closed (see Figure 3.3). Open economies have greater opportunity for export-led growth but are also more vulnerable to external shocks.

Income

The income measure of GDP is based on total incomes from production. It is essentially the total of-

 wages and salaries of employees;
 income from self-employment;
 trading profits of companies;
 trading surpluses of government corporations and enterprises; and
 income from rents.

These are known as factor incomes. GDP does not include transfer payments such as interest and dividends, pensions, or other social security benefits. The breakdown of incomes sheds additional light on economic behaviour because it is the counterpart to expenditure in what economists call the circular flow of money. It also provides a useful basis for forecasting inflation.

Accounting conventions. Incomes data are collected from figures which are based on common accounting conventions, rather

33
MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY

than the principles of national accounting. One result is that reported company profits include any increase or decrease in the value of inventories. A value (as opposed to a volume) change does not represent any real economic activity, so this stock appreciation is deducted from total domestic income to arrive at GDP. Britain's Office for National Statistics now uses a definition of profits that exclude the change in the value of stocks, so no stock-appreciation adjustment is shown in national accounts.

Discrepancies

In a perfect world, the output, expenditure and income measures would be identical. In practice there are discrepancies owing to inevitable shortcomings in data collection, differences in the reported timing of transactions and the black economy. The discrepancy between any pair of measures is typically up to 1-2% of GDP. It can be much larger than this, as it was in many countries in the mid-1970s when data collection was complicated by sharp oil price increases and rapid inflation.
	Since output, expenditure and income data are, by and large, collected independently, the safest approach is to take the average of the three as indicative of overall economic trends. Not many governments, however, publish such averages and it may not be practical to calculate them. Consequently it is usually necessary to focus on one.
	The output measure is usually the most reliable indicator of short-term developments (that is, up to one year) as the survey data are fairly concrete. For longer periods the expenditure measure is probably better, mainly because the weights used to aggregate the output indicators are updated at infrequent intervals and they become out of date. The income measure is usually the last available and least reliable.

PRICES

Market prices, factor cost and basic prices

Many transactions are subject to taxes and subsidies. Sales tax or value-added tax (VAT) and subsidised housing are obvious examples. The expenditure measure of GDP records market prices, which includes these taxes and subsidies. The income and output measures are generally reported at factor cost (that is, they exclude taxes and subsidies). The relationship is simple:

34

PRICES

GDP at market prices - indirect taxes + subsidies = GDP at factor cost

factor cost adjustment

The factor cost adjustment. The factor cost adjustment (the net total of taxes and subsidies) enables the income, expenditure and output measures to be converted freely between factor cost and market prices. This allows consistent comparisons and highlights the effect of government intervention.

Basic prices. Britain's official statisticians now call the basic output measure of GDP "gross value added (GVA) at basic prices". This includes subsidies and excludes taxes (eg VAT) on products only. GvA or GDP at factor cost also excludes taxes on production, such as business property taxes. The statisticians consider GvA at basic prices to be a better measure of short-term movements in the economy than the old factor-cost measure.

National conventions. Americans tend to measure economic activity at market prices right through to the net national product stage. They then adjust for taxes and subsidies to reach national income at factor cost. Thus a reference to American GDP probably means GDP at market prices. In Britain, the "headline" measure of GDP is at market prices. However, GvA at basic prices is also reported. The only way to be sure is to check the basis of the figures in question.

Current and constant prices

GDP figures are reported in current and constant prices.

Output data are generally collected in both current and constant prices. The constant price figures for each industry are obtained by valuing current output in the prices applicable in a given base year; say, 1990 or 1995.
Expenditure data are mostly collected in current prices. They are converted into constant prices by the same adjustment process used with output data, or - slightly differently - by deflating each component by an estimated price indicator. Once the current and constant price versions of the expenditure measure are available, they are used to calculate an overall deflator (that is, the price index) which is used with the income measure.
Income data are collected in current prices and converted into constant prices using deflators derived from the expenditure measure.
3 MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY

The deflator. The GDP deflator calculated from expenditure data at factor cost is also known as the implicit price deflator . This is a handy measure of economy-wide inflation trends, but it is affected by changes in the composition of GDP (see page 208).
	Adjusting for inflation is less reliable at times when prices are changing rapidly. Small errors in the measurements of current values and prices can combine to create large errors in the constant price series. Make it a rule to question the accuracy of price deflators. For example, 12% nominal GDP growth with inflation of 10% results in approximately 2% real growth in GDP. If inflation is actually slightly higher, at 11 %, real GDP growth is halved to a mere 1%.

PUTTING IT IN CONTEXT

Population

The notes on omissions (pages 27-28) suggest that output figures are a dubious guide to the quality of life. Nevertheless, total output per head (that is, GDP divided by the size of the population) is used as a broad indicator of living standards. A rise in real GDP that is greater than any increase in population is taken to indicate an improvement in economic well-being. However, if, for example, real GDP increases by 3% while population expands by 5%, the economy is "worse off' (that is, real GDP per head has declined).

Purchasing power

Output per head in current prices is a useful guide to levels of economic activity when making "snapshot" comparisons between countries. Since it is necessary, however, to convert the figures into a common currency, the underlying message can be distorted by exchange rate effects.

	The best solution is to use output per head on a purchasing power parity (PPP) basis, which adjusts for national variations in the prices paid for goods and services. This is not easy to calculate accurately, but some intergovernmental agencies such as the DECD produce estimates. Their figures show, for example, that although Switzerland's GDP per head is much higher than that of America if converted into dollars at current exchange rates, after adjusting for variations in prices the spending power of the Swiss is below that of Americans.

36

RELIABILITY

Employment

Another way of measuring relative activity is with output per person employed. This is an important measure of productivity which is discussed extensively in Chapter 4.

RELIABILITY

Some problems of obtaining information by surveys and samples are outlined above. In addition, the rush to publish information often means that figures are revised several times as new information comes to hand, perhaps causing major changes in interpretation. For example, industrial production figures may be based initially on sales and output data and adjusted later to take account of changes in inventories not caught in the sales figures.
	Statisticians go to great lengths to account for these and other problems. The techniques employed are reasonably reliable, at least in the more developed nations. It is important to remember, however, that published figures for GDP, average earnings, prices, and so on are only estimates.

Table 3.1 Government number-crunchers crunched

	Revisions$
Statisticians' percentage

Statisticians Government per 10,000 statistics budget
ranking			points Timelinessb population	per headbd

Canada						1	0.2	9	1.6	8.2
Australia						2	0.6	11	2.0	9.0
Netherlands 3						1.0	5=	2.0	7.6
France						4	0.3	5=	1.7	6.0
Sweden						5	, 	7

6=					0.3	2=	0.9 	4.2
Germany						6=	0.$	2=	1.9	8.0
USA						6=	0.3	1	0.6	8.8
Japes						9	, 0.8	10
Switzerland 10					0.4 	4

Italy						11	0.3	8	1.4	5.0
Spain						12	13	1.2	4.2
Belgium						13	...	12	1.3	3.6
a Average					absolute deviation between initial estimate of quarterly GDP

growth and latest revision, 1989-91. Belgium, Spain and Sweden did not publish figures for the full period.

b Average speed of publication of GDP, industrial production, consumer prices and trade (based on latest three published figures): 1 is fastest, 13 is slowest.

c Eli estimates from Eurostat, updated by The Economist, other figures from national statistic offices. d Converted at purchasing-power parity. Source: The Economist, September 11th 1993.
3 MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY

	Moreover, the basis on which some figures are calculated by less scrupulous governments does not stand up to close examination. Consumer-price indices are particularly vulnerable. They may include only selected subsidised goods and services and omit those which increase in price too rapidly.

y
The good statistics guide'

In 1993 The Economist asked a panel of statisticians in various countries to rank government statistical agencies in the 13 largest `, industrialised countries according to the objectivity of the agency (ie whether it is free from political interference), the reliability of figures, statistical methodology, and the relevance of published figures, such as coverage of service industries. Canada came out ~ top, followed by Australia, the Netherlands, France and Sweden (see Table 3.1).Italy, Spain and Belgium were bottom of the list.
	The Economist also looked at the average size of revisions to GDP '! growth in each country. Canada did well again with the smallest revisions to its figures. America, Britain, France and Italy similarly revised their figures relatively little, while Germany, the Netherlands and Japan revised theirs the most.
	However, Canada was also among the slowest to produce economic indicators. America, Germany and Britain were the fastest to get their numbers out. In terms of resources, Australia and the Netherlands had the highest proportion of statisticians. Australia was also the biggest spender on statistics per head.
	Perhaps the bottom line is that the reliability of economic indicators must always be questioned, and it is useful to try to de- ~ velop a feel for their accuracy.

GROWTH: TRENDS AND CYCLES

"When your neighbour loses his job, it's a slowdown; when you lose your
job, it's a recession; when an economist loses his job, it's a depression."
Anon

Chapter 3 focused on national income as a snapshot of economic activity. This chapter considers the interesting question of changes in economic activity over time. The introduction outlines the basic issues which affect growth. The GDP briefs explain how to interpret indicators of overall activity. The productivity brief shows how employment and investment lay down the basis for long-term growth. Finally the brief on cyclical indicators indicates the way that many economic series fluctuate around the trend.

Trends and cycles

Economic developments should be judged in the context of trends and cycles.

Trends. The trend is the long-term rate of economic expansion. The industrial economies have enjoyed a growth trend for decades or even centuries. Since the second world war the volume of goods and services that they produce has grown by 3-4% a year in general. Figure 4.1 shows the 1960-95 trend for the American economy.

Cycles. The cycle reflects short-term fluctuations around the trend. There are always a few months or years when growth is above trend, followed by a period when the economy contracts or grows below trend (see Figure 4.1).

Sources of growth

Long_terrn growth. In the long term the growth in economic output depends on the number of people working and output per worker (productivity).

Clearly there are limits to changes in the size of the population
