3 MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY

Moreover, the basis on which some figures are calculated by less scrupulous governments does not stand up to close examination. Consumer-price indices are particularly vulnerable. They may include only selected subsidised goods and services and omit those which increase in price too rapidly.

y

The good statistics guide'

In 1993 The Economist asked a panel of statisticians in various countries to rank government statistical agencies in the 13 largest `, industrialised countries according to the objectivity of the agency (ie whether it is free from political interference), the reliability of figures, statistical methodology, and the relevance of published figures, such as coverage of service industries. Canada came out ~ top, followed by Australia, the Netherlands, France and Sweden (see Table 3.1).Italy, Spain and Belgium were bottom of the list.

The Economist also looked at the average size of revisions to GDP '! growth in each country. Canada did well again with the smallest revisions to its figures. America, Britain, France and Italy similarly revised their figures relatively little, while Germany, the Netherlands and Japan revised theirs the most.

However, Canada was also among the slowest to produce economic indicators. America, Germany and Britain were the fastest to get their numbers out. In terms of resources, Australia and the Netherlands had the highest proportion of statisticians. Australia was also the biggest spender on statistics per head.

Perhaps the bottom line is that the reliability of economic indicators must always be questioned, and it is useful to try to de- ~ velop a feel for their accuracy.

GROWTH: TRENDS AND CYCLES

"When your neighbour loses his job, it's a slowdown; when you lose your
job, it's a recession; when an economist loses his job, it's a depression."
Anon

Chapter 3 focused on national income as a snapshot of economic activity. This chapter considers the interesting question of changes in economic activity over time. The introduction outlines the basic issues which affect growth. The GDP briefs explain how to interpret indicators of overall activity. The productivity brief shows how employment and investment lay down the basis for long-term growth. Finally the brief on cyclical indicators indicates the way that many economic series fluctuate around the trend.

Trends and cycles

Economic developments should be judged in the context of trends and cycles.

Trends. The trend is the long-term rate of economic expansion. The industrial economies have enjoyed a growth trend for decades or even centuries. Since the second world war the volume of goods and services that they produce has grown by 3-4% a year in general. Figure 4.1 shows the 1960-95 trend for the American economy.

Cycles. The cycle reflects short-term fluctuations around the trend. There are always a few months or years when growth is above trend, followed by a period when the economy contracts or grows below trend (see Figure 4.1).

Sources of growth

Long_terrn growth. In the long term the growth in economic output depends on the number of people working and output per worker (productivity).

Clearly there are limits to changes in the size of the population









4 GROWTH: TRENDS AND CYCLES

Figure 4.1

US trends and cycles
US GNP at market prices, 1992, $bn

7000

6000

5000-

4000

3000

2000 -

Trend

As published

1960				1965	1970	1975	1980	1985	1990	1995

Source: U5 Commerce Dept.

and the number of people in employment. On the other hand, only an extreme pessimist can see an end to long-term productivity improvements. Output per worker grows through technical progress and investment in new plant, machinery and equipment. Investment and productivity are therefore the basis for continued and sustained economic expansion.
	The Productivity brief (page 49) quantifies the relationship between employment, investment and growth. It is important to distinguish between economic growth, which may reflect nothing more than an expanding population, and overall economic welfare which, if measured by the volume of goods and services produced per person, improves only if output grows faster than the population.
	See GDP and GDP per head, pages 41-46.

Short-term cycles. The brief on Cyclical indicators (page 51) explains the way that economic growth fluctuates around the trend. The brief is important because it lays the basis for interpreting many economic indicators. For example, a downturn in housing starts or an increase in inventories may signal a recession perhaps 12 months hence.

The circular flow of incomes. Firms and households are the backbone of an economy. Firms employ people to make goods and provide services. This gives households their incomes. Household spending provides the rationale for the existence of firms. Thus the circular flow continues; in short, output = income = expenditure.
There are leakages from and injections to the circular flow.

40

NOMINAL GDP

Money is taken out of circulation when people buy imports, save or pay taxes. This means less spending, so firms sell fewer goods and services. Money is put into circulation when people run down their savings or borrow, when governments spend their taxes and when foreigners buy exports. These actions boost spending, so firms sell more goods and services.
	All leakages and injections affect spending power and influence savings and investment decisions. These may be thought of as causing cyclical variations while productivity determines longterm growth. Life is never simple, of course, and productivity depends on investment, which in turn depends on many factors including the cycle itself.

Inflation and volumes

Higher demand can easily result in inflation. For example, if employers increase wages without raising output, and if the extra incomes are spent in full, prices will be pulled up (demand-pull inflation) but there will be no increase in real welfare.
	The effects of inflation are wide and far-reaching. They are particularly relevant when analysing small parts of the economy in great detail, such as when projecting earnings and share prices for one company. For assessing the economy as a whole it is better to focus on the volume of output rather than its nominal money value, and to think in volume or inflation-adjusted constant price terms. These concepts are discussed in Chapter 2; Chapter 13 reviews inflation in detail.

NOMINAL GDP

Measures: 		Total economic activity in current prices.
Significance:	Describes the total level of production. Use as a yardstick for measuring "economic achievement" or other indicators (such as the current-account balance as a percentage of GDP).
Presented as: Quarterly and annual totals.
Focus on:		Totals. Use factor cost when reviewing output or incomes,
	market prices if looking at expenditure patterns.
Yardstick: The oECO total was $22,373 billion in 1998.
Released: Quarterly, I-3 months in arrears; frequently revised.

Interpretation

Norninal GDP or GNI (GNP) is used to measure total economic activity. 'Me choice between the two depends largely on national conventions (see page 26). Where GN1/GNP is higher than GDP it indicates net investment income from abroad.
4 GROWTH: TRENDS AND CYCLES

	The annual total ranges from under $1 billion in some African countries to over $7,000 billion in America. For countries at similar stages of development, magnitude depends largely on population size. (See GDP per head and Real GDP, pages 43 and 44.)

Table 4.1 Nominal GDP, 1998

GDP		GNI GNI as
of total $bn				$PPPa	bnb	bnbof GDP

Australia			1.6	351.9	425.6 579.5	561.7	96.9
Austria			1.0	232.5	193.9 2,622.6	2,616.6	99.8
Belgium			1.1	250.5	245.9 9,064.0	9,189.0	101.4
Canada			2.6	581.7	748.9 895.7	866.2	96.7
Denmark			0.8	174.9	139.4 1,166.6	1,147.2	98.3 r
France			6.4	1,433.9	1,299.8 8,224.9	8,147.4	99.1
Germany			9.5	2,135.7	1,877.3 4,156.0
Italy			5.2	1,172.3	1,253.5 1,950,700.0	1,690,500.0	86.7
	Japan				16.9	3,777.2	3,049.1	506,977.0	...	...
	Netherlands				1.7	377.5	362.2	750.6	755.5	100.7
	Spain				2.5	553.3	659.2	77,897.0	76,762.0	98.5
	Sweden				1.0	226.9	187.8	1,800.6	...	...
	Switzerland				1.2	263.8	189.1	383.4	...	...
	UK				6.1	1,357.2	1,253.6	800.9	813.1	101.5
	USA				36.8	8,230.9	8,178.8	8,510.7	8,490.5	99.8
	EU				37.3	8,345.9	7,986.1	...	...	...
	DECD 100.0 22,373.0 23,149.9				...	...	...

a Purchasing power parity; where output is adjusted for variations in spending power. b National currency. France, Italy, Spain and UK, 1997.

Source: IMF; DECD.

Figure 4.2

Total GDP
PPP basis, 1998, Sbn

10,000

a,ooo

s.ooo

4,000

z,ooo

0

scarce: oECO.

42

1,254 1,254
F1 [71 749 659 426				362 246	194	189

~,Qa Ve~ac1 ~~acce			J~	1 La as "'ZacP~SCa\~acas~e~J P~`a~,e0caS

~T

GDP PER HEAD

Figure 4.3

GDP per head
ppP basis, 1998

30,000-

25.000 _

zo.ooo-

u.ooo-

10,000 _

s.aoo-

o-

S~ - o
	0 Source: OECD.

GDP PER HEAD

Measures: Output per person; GDP divided by population size. Significance: Used as an indicator of overall economic welfare.
Presented as:		Quarterly and annual totals.
Focus on:		Nominal totals; changes in real terms.
Yardstick: 		The OECD average was $20,826 per head in 1998
Released:		Annually, sometimes quarterly; well in arrears; frequently
	revised.

What to look for

Output per head is a good guide to living standards. It implicitly allows for qualitative factors such as literacy or health although these are not covered directly.
	In 1998, annual output per head was below $200 in some African states, and a mere $100 in Ethiopia, while the world median was around $2,000. The output per head of the rich industrial countries was at least ten times greater than the median. After adjusting for variations in purchasing power, the gap between the richest and poorest countries looks narrower. Even so, the richest countries' output per head was comfortably more than five times the median, at well over $20,000. Ethiopia's was a mere $500.
	If real GDP per head increases it indicates an improvement in overall economic well-being.

43
GROWTH: TRENDS AND CYCLES

Table 4.2 GDP per head, 1998

Australia		18,656
Austria		26,210
Belgium		24,432
Canada		19,0$6
Denmark		32,934
France		24,398
Germany		26,056
Italy		20,323
Japan		30,025
Netherlands		24,107
Spain		14,129
Sweden		25,852
Switzerland		36,869
UK		23,006
USA		30,514
EU average		22,285
OECD average 20,826

Sources: IMF; OECD.

National currency

Real GDP
annual % chance
1992-971998

	22,689		30,389
	23,985		324,454
	24,097		886,857
	24,486		28,314
	26,280		220,690
	22,091		143,936
	22,835		45,850
	21,739		35,284,793
	24,109		393,057
	23,082		47,821
	16,740		211,087
	212,131		205,520
	26,576		53,453
	21,170		13,889
	30,514		30,514
	21,286		23,125
	21,042		...

4.1 1.8
1.6
3.1
3.2
1.3
1.4
1.2
1.5
2.6
1.9
1.6
0.5
3.1
3.1
1.9
2.6

REAL GDP

Measures: Significance: Presented as: Focus on: Yardstick:

	Total economic activity in constant prices.
	Most useful for tracking developments overtime.
	Quarterly and annual totals.
	Percentage changes, annual or over four quarters.
	The oECO average was 2.396 a year growth during the ~,j: ,
	period I 985-95.	' :r
Released:		Quarterly, I-3 months in arrears; frequently revised.'''

What to look for

Real (constant price) GDP or GDP figures reveal changes in economic output after adjusting for inflation. These should be put in the context of the cycle (see Cyclical indicators, page 51). Strong economic growth following a recession may simply indi cafe that slack capacity is being put back into use (see Unemployment and Capacity use, pages 63 and 107).
	Strong growth when the economy is already buoyant may indicate the installation of new capacity which will add still more td future output (see Investment, Chapter 8). However, excel growth at the top of the cycle may bubble over into inflatio . and/or imports (see Chapter 13).

44

World cycles

	Developing countries have the capacity for faster GDP growth than more mature industrial economies. Real growth of around 3% per annum is good for America and Europe. The newly industrialising countries of the Pacific rim were managing at least double that before the Asian crisis of 1997. They are expected to resume growth at much higher rates than mature economies, even if they do not match their former giddy pace.

The inflation/output trade-off

The change in real GDP plus the change in the deflator (see page 35) approximately equals the change in nominal GDP. For example, if real output rises by 3% and inflation is S%, nominal output has risen by about 8%. Some economists argue that aggregate demand determines nominal GDP and that there is a trade-off between real output and inflation: each can rise by any amount so long as the total equals the change in nominal output. Higher inflation therefore means lower growth in output.

For the industrialised world, 1960, 1968, 1973 and 1979 were peak years for economic activity. There was another peak around the start of the 1990s, but it was unusual in that it was staggered across countries (see Cyclical indicators, page 51). Table 4.3 shows

economic growth rates within each cycle, which provide useful yardsticks for judging future growth rates.

Industrial economies. The 1960s were a period of rapid expansion, due at least in part to technological advances and freedom

from external shocks. The 1973 and 1979 oil price rises caused temporary setbacks. Japan was perhaps more badly hit by the first; Europe and America suffered more from the second. Growth was rapid again in the mid-late 1980s. The mid-decade fall in oil prices and policy responses to it may have helped extend the cycle, but many countries failed to get total output back up to trend.

Developing countries. The oil producers enjoyed rapid growth rates in the 1970s and suffered the greatest setbacks in the 1980s. Broadly similar patterns were recorded by many Latin American and African countries, with the slowdown in the 1980s reflecting the debt crisis, a lack of inward investment and shortages of foreign exchange. East European countries also had feeble growth in the 1980s, reflecting the shortcomings of their planned economies.

45
4 GROWTH: TRENDS AND CYCLES

Table 4.3		Four world cycles
	Annual % change in real GDP
		Two cycles disaggregated ;
	Four cycles		down up down up

1960-68 68-73 73-79 79-90		1973-75 75-79 79-83 83-90

Australia					5.0	5.3	2.6	3.1	1.8	3.0	1.5	4.0
Belgium				4.6	5.6	2.3	2.2	1.3	2.8	1.3	2.7
Canada				5.5	5.4	4.3	2.8	3.5	4.7	1.1	3.7
France				5.4	5.5	2.8	2.1	1.4	3.5	1.5	2.6
Germany					4.0	4.9	2.3	2.0	-0.6	3.9	0.6	2.9
Italy			5.7		4.6	3.7	2.4	1.3	4.9	1.7	2.9
Japan				10.1	8.8	3.6	4.1	1.0	4.9	3.3	4.6
Netherlands					5.0	4.7	2.6	1.7	1.9	3.0	0.1	2.7
Spain				7.5	6.6	2.2	2.8	2.9	1.9	1.0	3.8
Sweden				4.4	3.8	1.8	1.9	3.0	1.2	1.1	2.4
Switzerland					4.4	4.6	-0.2	2.3	-2.8	1.1	1.5	2.8
UK			3.0		3.3	1.5	2.1	-1.1	2.9	0.5	3.1
USA			4.5		3.0	2.6	2.6	-0.9	4.3	0.7	3.7 ,
EU average					4.3	4.7	2.4	2.2	0.0	3.6	0.9	2.9
	DECD average 5.2				4.2	2.8	2.7	-0.4	4.4	1.3	3.6

Source: DECD.

GDP: OUTPUT

Measures: 		GDP according to sector (agriculture, mining, manufacturing
	and service industries).
Significance:		Provides analysis of total output at a high level of detail.
Presented as:		Quarterly and annual totals.
Focus on:		Real growth rates.
Yardstick:		Overall real growth in the GDP total.
Released: 		Quarterly, I-3 months in arrears; frequently revised.

What to look for

Compare the percentage change in each sector with the overall percentage change in GDP. A sector which is growing faster than the average is making a very positive contribution to growth. A sector which is growing less rapidly than the average is clawing it down.
A change in a dominant sector has a larger effect on total acti~
ity than a change in a smaller sector. For example, in the industri
al economies a 1 % rise in services boosts GDP by more than a
similar increase in agriculture. Indeed, the mature industrialised
countries have been undergoing a shift from manufacturing to
services. In the OECD countries, services' share of output has
risen from 45% in 1960 to 64% in the 1990s. 		,'

46

GDP: EXPENDITURE

Figure 4.4

GDP growth
Real GDP, annual average % change, 1990-98

4
	3.3
		3.0
3

z

1 -

 ~`a~a JSP

P

Source: OECD.

	In general developing countries depend more on agriculture or, if they are at a later stage of development, manufacturing. Chapter 9 reviews individual indicators of output.

Table 4.4 Dominant sectors
Output as % of GDP

General trend

Agriculture
Cambodia			51	undeveloped
Laos			$2
Manufacturing
China			37	developing
Malaysia			34
Services
Netherlands			70	developed
USA			71

Source: World Bank.

GDP: EXPENDITURE

Measures:		SDP according to category of spending (consumption,
	investment and net exports).
Significance:		Provides detailed analysis of total spending.
Presented as:		Quarterly and annual totals.
Focus on:		Real growth rates.
Yardstick:		Overall real growth in the GDP total.
Released:		Quarterly, I-3 months in arrears; frequently revised.
4 GROWTH: TRENDS AND CYCLES

What to look for

As with the GDP output breakdown, compare the percentage change in each category of spending with the overall percentage growth in GDP in the same period.

Personal consumption. Growth in this category often leads a general recovery from recession, encouraging manufacturers to invest more. However, if consumption grows faster than the productive capacity of an economy, imports are sucked in and inflation rises. Personal consumption typically accounts for 60% of GDP, so a change in consumption has a big effect on total output.

Government spending. This reflects, to some extent, politics rather than market forces. Its share in GDP is higher in countries where the state provides many services. A short-term increase in government spending can provide a stabilising boost to the economy, but in general it diverts resources from productive growth.

Investment. This is a key component, contributing to current growth and laying down the foundation for future expansion. Look for spending on machinery (which produces more output) rather than, say, dwellings.

Changes in stocks. These can be erratic. They decline when demand is growing more rapidly than production (a good sign at the beginning of a recovery, potentially inflationary at the end) or when manufacturers and distributors are squeezed and are trying to cut the cost of holding stocks. Inventories tend to rise when demand slows.

Exports and imports. Exports contribute to overall GDP growth; higher imports reduce the increase in output relative to the growth in demand. A sudden increase in import penetration (imports divided by GDP) suggests that consumer demand is growing faster than the domestic economy can cope with (overheating). A longer-term increase in imports relative to export may imply a decline in the competitiveness of domestic producers. Imports that are substantially larger than exports may point to exchange-rate problems.

48

PRODUCTIVITY

PgODUCTIVITY

Measures: Significance: Presented as:

Focus on: Yardstick:

	Output for one unit of labour or capital.
	Indicator of efficiency and potential total economic output.
	Index numbers.
	Trend, especially relative to other countries.
	OECD average growth in real GDP per worker was 1.6% a
	year during I 990-98.
Released:		Sometimes monthly, often two months in arrears;
	frequently revised.

Overview

Productivity measures the amount of output that is produced with given amounts of factor inputs (mainly land, labour and capital). Land is basically fixed and capital is very difficult to measure, so attention tends to focus on labour productivity. This can be defined in various ways. The most common are as follows.

 Output per worker = total output divided by total employment.
 Output per man hour = total output divided by hours worked.

Labour productivity reflects capital investment and offers a guide to capital productivity. A company using high-tech machinery will probably produce more per person than a company using nineteenth century steam technology (such as in eastern Europe). Other factors which affect labour productivity include social attitudes, work ethics, unionisation and, perhaps most important, training. These are not measured directly by economic statistics.

The arithmetic of growth

Economic growth reflects growth of the labour force plus growth of labour productivity.
	Labour productivity, in turn depends on new investment (which raises the capitalaabour ratio, which is known as factor substitution in economic jargon) and technological progress (which increases output for a given capitalaabour ratio).
	Table 4.5 shows trends in the major industrial economies. Data are presented in terms of four economic cycles (see Cyclical indicators, page 51).

Interpretation

Productivity
are		figures can be calculated in money terms, but they
	generally produced as index numbers. As a result, analysts

49
4 GROWTH: TRENDS AND CYCLES

Table 4.5 Sources of economic growth in industrial economies Annual % change

	Golden		Inflation
	age		& slump
	1960-73		1973-79

Technological progress			2.8	0.6
Factor substitutions		1.3	0.9
Total labour productivity			4.1	1.5
Labour inputb		1.1	1.4
Total output		5.2	2.9

Consoli
dation
1979-g9

0.8
1.0
1.7
1.0
2.7

a Growth in the capitalaabour ratio X the share of profits in national income
b Growth in employment corrected for (falling) hours worked per week.

Source: World Bank.

often look at changes over time and disregard the important question of the base from which the index numbers are calculated. If this was a period of high or low productivity, changes will be distorted.
	Nevertheless, trends are important. If output per person increases by 5%, an identical increase in wage rates may leave profitability unchanged. Indeed, since total labour costs (including, for example, the cost of providing recreational facilities for workers) may increase less rapidly than wages, profitability may actually improve. (See Wages and Unit labour costs, pages 200 and 204.)

Cycles. Productivity is highly cyclical since employment and capital are less flexible than demand and output. When production falls after a peak in economic activity, employment declines less rapidly and output per head plummets.
	When demand for goods and services increases after a recession, slack capacity is called into use and productivity rises rapidly.

Comparisons

When comparing absolute levels of productivity (rather than trends) remember that productivity also depends on technology and costs. Companies in Asia have a lower dollar value of output per person, but can still be more profitable than European Or American companies because labour costs are cheaper in Asia. _
	Exchange-rate changes are also important for comparisons of competitiveness (see page 154).

50

CYCLICAL OR LEADING INDICATORS

Tabs 4, (, Growth of productivity
Annual % change in real GDP per worker

Two cycles disaggregated
Four cycles				down	up	downup

1960-68 68-73 73-79 79-90 1973-75 75-79 79-83 83-90

Australia										4.0	4.9	2.3	2.2 2.4 2.6 1.8 0.8	1.3	2.8	2.4	1
Belgium										.9
Canada									2.3	2.4	1.4	1.0	0.5	1.8	0.4	1.4
France									4.9	4.3	2.5	2.1	1.5	3.0	1.7	2.3
Germany									4.1	4.3	2.8	1.4	1.5	3.5	0.5	1.9
Italy									6.2	4.9	2.8	2.0	0.0	4.1	1.3	2.4
Japan									8.5	7.7	2.9	3.0	1.4	3.6	2.1	3.4
Netherlands									3.8	4.1	2.3	1.4	2.2	2.4	1.4	1.4
Spain									6.9	5.7	3.2	2.5	3.3	3.2	3.2	2.1
Sweden									4.0	3.0	0.5	1.1	0.6	0.5	0.8	1.4
Switzerland									2.9	3.1	0.7	1.4	-0.4	1.2	0.2	2.2
	2.7								3.1	1.3	1.6	-0.9	2.5	2.2	1.2
USA									2.6	0.7	0.0	0.9	-1.3	0.7	0.2	1.2
EU average									4.1	4.2	2.3	1.7	0.2	3.3	1.4	1.8
DECD average 4.1								2.9	1,6	1.7	-0.6	2.8	1.0	2.2

Source: DECD.

CYCLICAL OR LEADING INDICATORS

Measures: 		The economic cycle.
Significance: Useful tool for short-term predictions of economic activity. Presented as: Index numbers.
Focus on: Trends.
Yardstick: Look for turning points.
Released: 		Monthly, at least one month in arrears; frequently revised.

Overview

In developed economies at least, GDP progresses erratically around its long-term growth trend. There are periods when growth spurts ahead, followed by periods of recession. This variation is known as the economic, business or trade cycle. It repeats every five years or so, although no two cycles are ever of the same magnitude or duration.
	The cycle has four phases: expansion, peak, recession and trough.

Expansion. When demand first increases, for whatever reason, it gathers momentum automatically. The first sign is often a rundown in inventories. Output then rises faster than demand while
4 GROWTH: TRENDS AND CYCLES

these are rebuilt (see Stocks [inventories], page 96). Compares take on unemployed workers, who spend their new income on postponed purchases of consumer goods. This creates more demand and companies employ more people, and so the process continues (the multiplier). Before long producers come up against capacity constraints. If they are confident that demand win remain buoyant (expectations), they invest more in new plant and machinery, which generates even more demand (the accelerator).

Peak. The upward momentum cannot continue indefinitely. Eventually output hits a ceiling owing to bottlenecks and supply constraints. Demand for investment funds may push up interest rates to the point where new investment is not profitable, or at full employment there may be no more workers to take on. Consumer demand may be steady, but the fall in investment demand pulls back the level of total output.

Recession. With investment demand falling, producers of capital goods start to cut back on labour. Higher unemployment reduces consumer demand. The inventories, multiplier, expectations and accelerator principles work in reverse and the economic contraction gathers momentum.

Trough. Output will not fall indefinitely. It will stop at some minimum level (a trough or depression) because employees retain jobs and spending power where they work in government or in industries supplying food, basic essentials and perhaps export goods. Unemployment and welfare payments, past saving and new borrowing enable other consumers to buy essentials.
	Slack demand for investment funds may pull back interest rates making new or replacement investment attractive, at least for the industries providing basic essentials. And with consumer demand steady, investment demand begins to lift the economy again.

	In America a recession is technically defined as two consecutive quarters -of falling GDP. The snag with this is that if GDP plunges steeply in the first and third quarters of a year, but rises slightly in the second and fourth quarters, then officially an economy has escaped a recession, even though output may end the year sharply lower. Some economists prefer to define a recession as a year-on-year fall in output. Others talk about a "growth recession" when a country's GDP growth rate falls below its longterm productive potential. In Japan, for example, annual growth of less than 3% has commonly been called a recession.
	Table 4.7 shows dates for the most recent peaks and trough in selected countries before the end of 1993.

52

CYCLICAL OR LEADING INDICATORS

Table 4.7 Peaks and troughs in GDP Quarter/year

	Peak						Trough	Peak	Trough	Peak	Trough
Australia							-	2/83	3/85	3/88	2/89	2/91
Belgium								1/80	-	-	1/8'7	-	_
Canada								1/79	4/82	-	-	1/89	1/91
France								3/79	-	-	1/85	2/89	1/93
Germany								1/80	4/82	-	-,	4/90	-
Italy								1/80	2/83	-	-	1/88	1/93
Japan								1/80	4/83	2/85	2/87	1/88	-
Netherlands								4/79	1/83	-	-	2/89	1/93
Spain								1/80	2/85	-	-	1/88	-
Sweden								1/80	1/83	-	-	4/87	1/93
Switzerland								3/81	4/82	-	-	3/89	1/93
	2/79							3/82	-	-	4/88	2/91
USA								4/78	4/82	-	-	1/89	2/91
EU average								1/80	2/84	-	-	1/88	1/93
OECD average 1/80						4/82	-	-	1/88	1/91

Note: These peaks and troughs identified by the DECD those identified by national authorities.

Source: OECD.

Causes

may differ from

There is no general consensus about what causes cycles or even about what is a cause and what is an effect. Major influences include fixed investment and inventory cycles, external shocks and well-meaning or perhaps self-interested government policies. It is not unknown for the government of the day to engineer an economic boom just before an election, thus setting the cycle in motion. Expansionary policies aimed at reducing unemployment followed by contractionary policies to limit the inflationary consequences can cause severe cyclical swings. Moreover, measures to cool a boom may be imposed when automatic contractionary forces are already in motion, thus hastening the downhill slide.

Cyclical patterns in economic indicators

Cyclical patterns can be detected in many economic series. Peaks
	n troughs ughs do not fall in step. This means that indicators which
		advance of GDP can be used to predict economic devel
opments. The following timings indicate roughly what might be
expected in a standard cycle in an industrial economy.
	(Some economists argue that interest rates are a lagging indicator. They are included here as a leading indicator since most People are familiar with the idea of, say, lowering interest rates to boost a flagging economy.)

53
4 GROWTH: TRENDS AND CYCLES

Leading indicators. Interest rates pass their low point and begin to rise about 18 months ahead of a peak in output.
	Business confidence, share prices, housing starts and companies' financial surpluses peak 8-16 months ahead of output. Consumer credit, car sales and manufacturing orders peak about six months ahead. Retail sales peak 2-3 months in advance.

Coincident indicators. GDP establishes the reference point for the overall cycle, while other indicators which peak within a month or two of GDP are used to confirm that the economy is turning.

Lagging indicators. Manufacturing capacity utilisation peaks about a month after total output. Job vacancies peak about three months later, growth in average earnings after four months and growth in unit labour costs after five months. Productivity and unemployment stop falling and turn upwards six months after the peak in overall activity, and inflation peaks at about that time also. Investment, order backlogs and stocks peak around 12 months after output.

The cyclical indicators

Several countries and OECD statisticians have combined groups of economic indicators into composite cyclical indicators. Generally trends are removed, erratic fluctuations are smoothed, and the series are combined into weighted averages in index form.
	The components of the indices vary, reflecting changes in economic habits and analysts' understanding of the economy. For example, in the early 1990s America downgraded the role of share prices after it was found that an increase in stockmarket values was taken as an indicator of an upturn, which prompted share buying and pushed up the leading indicator still further.

Interpretation. Use composite indicators as a guide to the cycle. Leading indicators turn 6-12 months ahead of GDP; coincident indicators turn with it; lagging indicators turn perhaps six months later.
	Watch mainly for changes in direction in leading indicators and use coincident indicators to confirm the change. Most composite indicators are used only to identify turning points. However, American indicators are scaled so that percentage changes are broadly suggestive of the magnitude of fluctuations in the overall level of economic activity.

54

CYCLICAL OR LEADING INDICATORS

	Composite indicators are frequently published when only a few components are available and are revised in subsequent months as more information comes to hand and as component indicators are themselves revised. The composites should be interpreted with care and supplemented by examination of individual economic series.

55
