5 POPULATION, EMPLOYMENT AND UNEMPLOYMENT

decreases. When there is no more labour available (when the NAIRu is reached), demand bubbles over into inflation or imports. Strong consumer demand is less likely to be inflation, if the unemployment rate is well above the NAIRu rather than close to it. During the mid- and late 1990s, unemployment has continued to decline in America and Britain below the unenl_ ployment rate previously thought to be the NAIRU, with few signs of inflationary pressure. Economists therefore think that the NAIRu has declined in these two countries during the 1990s.

Longer-term trends

Unemployment in the industrial countries started to rise again in the early 1990s. It reached more than 8% of the labour force in 1993 and 1994, and has since fallen back to about 7%. The rate is higher in Europe (10% in 1998) than in America (4.5%), where flexible labour markets and strong economic growth have pulled unemployment down, or Japan (below 3%), where jobs for life are part of the culture.

The structure of unemployment helps to identify problem areas. In 1998 long-term unemployment (those unemployed for more than six months) was almost half of total unemployment. However, it was lower in Japan (39%) and America (14%).

Other clues

The monthly change in unemployment is a good guide to economic developments. Compare the last 2-3 months with the average change in the same period of the previous year. Most figures are seasonally adjusted, but watch out for the effects of severe weather or industrial disputes.

Other figures, such as weekly claims for unemployment benefit, job advertisements for help wanted and vacancies, provide useful back-up to unemployment figures.

Regional unemployment figures provide a guide to structural unemployment since they highlight the relationship between job losses and the location of known twilight industries.

66

FISCAL INDICATORS

"Blessed are the young, for they shall inherit the national debt.
Herbert Hoover

Fiscal indicators are concerned with government revenue and expenditure, which are significant influences on the circular flow of incomes (see pages 40-41). Taxes and duties take money out, while spending is an injection. In any one day or year the American government spends more than any other government, company or other organisation anywhere in the world.

Fiscal activities allow governments to provide services, redistribute incomes and influence the overall level of economic activity. They are one of the government's tools for controlling the economy. Others include monetary policy (see Chapter 12) and direct intervention and controls over wages, prices and industrial activity.

TAXES

The grabbing hand of government is as rapacious as ever. In 11 of the 15 rich countries in our figure, tax revenues have risen as a share of GDP in the 1990s, according to the OECD. The biggest rise has been in Italy, where taxes are up from 38.90 of GDP in 1990 to 43.5% last year. But the tax burden has also increased in less interventionist economies, such as America and Britain. In four countries the tax share has fallen: Sweden, the Netherlands, Spain and Japan. Sweden's taxes are down from 55.6% of GDP in 1990 to 53.0% in 1998, but they are still the highest in the table. Taxes in the Netherlands have declined proportionately the most, from 446% Of GDP t0 41.0%.

The Economist, November 13th 1999 (see also figure on next page)









6 FISCAL INDICATORS

Tax revenues
as % of GDP		Fl"- 1990M1998

Denmar4

Belgium

Franc f

Austria

Netherlands

German

eanade

Switzerlanr

Spain

United States

Australi:

Japan

Sowce: OECD.

.west Germany. 1,997

Level of government

Various problems of definition arise because of different treatment of financial transactions by central government, ' authorities, publicly owned enterprises, and so on.
	In an attempt to standardise, international organisations such as the OECD focus on general government, which covers central and local authorities, separate social security funds where apphcable, and province or state authorities in federations such as North America, Australia, Germany, Spain and Switzerland.
	Watch out for fiscal fraud: spending can be shifted to publicly owned enterprises which are generally classified as being outside general government. Net lending to such enterprises is part of government spending, but it is not always included in "headline
expenditure figures.

PUBLIC EXPENDITURE

Tinning

Many governments run their accounts on a calendar year basis. Britain, Canada and Japan have financial years which cover the 12 months to March 31 st; Australia's and Sweden's fiscal years run to June 30th; and America's ends on September 30th.

PUBLIC EXPENDITURE

Measures: 		Spending by the government.
Significance: Affects aggregate demand, size of the budget deficit. Presented as: Monthly and annual totals in current prices.
Focus on: Total, trends.
Yardstick:		OECD average public expenditure was 39.3% of GDP
	between 1990 and 1998.
Released: 		Monthly, at least one month in arrears.

The cycle and the automatic stabiliser

Government spending provides services including law and order, defence, education and health, roads, and so on. Such spending is an injection to the circular flow of income and has a considerable effect on aggregate demand. It is a stabilising influence to the extent that payments of welfare benefits increase when unemployment rises, which helps to maintain consumer spending.

Classification

Public spending may be classified in several different ways.

By level of government: central and local authorities, state or provincial authorities for federations, social security funds and public corporations.
By department: agriculture, defence, trade, and so on.
BY function: such as environmental services, which might be provided by more than one department.
By economic category: current, capital, and so on.

In order to interpret the economic effect of public spending, its breakdown into current and capital spending is usually most instructive.

Current spending

Major categories of current spending include the following.
6 FISCAL INDICATORS

Pay of public sector employees: this generally seems to rise faster than other current spending.
Other current spending: on goods and services such as stationery, medicines, uniforms, and so on.
Subsidies: on goods and services such as public housing and agricultural support.
Social security: including benefits for sickness, old age, family allowances, and so on; social assistance grants and unfunded employee welfare benefits paid by general government.
Interest on the national debt.

Interest payments reflect the size of the national debt (see page 78) and the level of interest rates. In 1998 net interest payments ranged from 9.1% of GDP in Greece to -0.7% in Norway.
	Social security transfers do not directly create output and are not included when measuring GDP. Their size reflects the level of state support, demographics and the economic cycle. Payments are mostly financed by specific employers' and employees' contributions. Where these are passed through a separate social security budget, "headline" spending figures are lower. National accounting conventions also affect the figures. For example, the British government counts the working families' tax credit, a means of support for low-paid people with children introduced in 1999, as a deduction from tax revenues. The payment it replaced, family credit, was counted as social-security expenditure. The effect of the change is to reduce the headline spending figure.
	Subsidies are caught in the market price measure of GDP, but are added back in as part of the adjustment to a factor cost basis. They range from less than 1% of GDP in America and Japan to nearly 5% in Sweden.
	Other current spending on pay and other goods and services makes up the "government consumption" component of GDP on an expenditure basis. This exceeds 20% of GDP in countries such as Sweden and Denmark where many services are supplied by the government rather than the private sector.

Capital spending

Capital spending is mainly fixed investment in infrastructure and dwellings. Note that some spending is arbitrarily classified as current spending even when there is a considerable capital outlay, such as in defence. Also current spending on things such as education, industrial training and research and development might be regarded as investment although they are never classified as such in economic figures.

70

PUBLIC EXPENDITURE

	This capital spending is part of investment in the expenditure measure of GDP. Public sector investment ranges from around l.s% of GDP Ill Britain and America to a massive 5% in Japan.

patterns and targets

Money public spending figures are rarely seasonally adjusted, although mere is often a definite pattern of spending during the fiscal year. Eliminate this by comparing the latest 2-3 months with the same period 12 months earlier, or the fiscal year to date with the same part of the previous year, but note that the smoothing effect will be smaller at the start of the year (perhaps covering only two months) than the end (when perhaps 11 months are included).
	The year-to-date comparison is useful for judging spending in relation to budget projections. For example, if in the first six months of the fiscal year spending is 5% up from the previous first half and expenditure is projected to rise by 2% during the year as a whole, it is a fair bet that the government is overspending. However, watch for any erratic items which distort the seasonal pattern.
	Spending tends to rise above target if the economy grows more slowly than expected. Always ask whether government economic forecasts are realistic when looking at expenditure projections.

Prices

Monthly government spending figures are always presented in nominal money terms. Judge their influence on the real level of economic activity by deflating them. For example, if government Figure 6.1

General government spending
010 of GDP, 1998

70
60.8
60
	55-1 54.6
5p				51.0 49.4 49.1
			47.5 47.2 46.9
b
3a
m
10
0

4~.1		4~.8 40.8 39.4

36.9

	'ec
~'					~a+ ce J1~	~a ~~ale ca6' act aaa 	c
		Oec "o- 0ey
			J .e V
6 FISCAL INDICATORS

consumption rises by 10% and inflation is 6%, the real level of such consumption is 4% higher.
	Choosing an appropriate deflator requires care. Table 13.1 shows that prices in the public and private sectors can increase at different rates. If public servants tolerate larger price rises than private individuals, then prices in the public sector will rise faster than in the private sector. If the public sector is facing a cash squeeze, then prices may rise more slowly in the public sector.
	Quarterly and annual spending figures are available in volume terms. The consumption component can be found in GDP data, although public investment is not usually distinguished separately from private investment in the main GDP breakdowns.

Table 6.1 General government spending, 1996 		w
	of GDP

Total Defence Public Education Health Social
	order

		Housing
	security		& comm
	& welfare		unity
		amenities

Australia				16.7	1.7	1.3	3.5	3.1	1.0	0.4
Austria				18.4	0.9	0.9	4.3	5.1	3.4	-0.1
Belgium				16.5	2.5	1.6	6.1	0.5	1.0	0.2
Denmark				25.2	1.8	1.0	5.6	5.0	6.7	0.2
France				19.8	3.1	0.9	5.2	3.4	1.5	1.4
Germany				19.9	1.4	1.6	3.7	6.6	3.0	0.3
Italy				16.3	1.7	1.7	4.2	3.4	0.7	0.5
Japan				9.7	0.9	...	3.2	0.4	0.7	0.7
	Netherlands 14.0				2.7	...	4.5	...	0.7	...
Spain				16.7	1.5	2.1	3.8	4.0	0.8	0.8
Sweden				26.2	2.4	1.4	5.1	4.6	5.7	0.5
UK				21.1	3.2	2.0	4.5	5.7	1.9	0.6
USA				15.7	...	...	...	...	...	...

	Source: DECD.

GOVERNMENT REVENUES

Measures:		Government receipts mainly from taxes and duties.	`
Significance: Affects aggregate demand; finances (partly) govemmerri,
-

spending.

Presented as: Focus on: Yardstick:

	Monthly and annual totals in current prices.
	Total; trends.	751
	Compare with spending (see Budget balance, page
	OECD receipts averaged 36. I % of GDP between 1990
	1998.
Released:		Monthly, at least one month in arrears.

72

GOVERNMENT REVENUES

overview

Government revenues are raised largely through taxes, social security contributions, fees or charges for services, and some miscellaneous sources such as interest on government loans. A few governments also conduct trading activities which generate

income.
	For the industrial countries as a group in the 1980s, personal income taxes, payroll taxes (largely social security) and taxes on spending each accounted for 25-30% of the total tax take. The remaining 16% came mainly from taxes on company profits and property.

Asset sales. One other source of income is receipts from the privatisation of activities previously undertaken by the public sector. In some countries, such as Britain, the receipts are classified as "negative expenditure". Either way, they have a once-off effect on public finances which is perhaps akin to selling the family silver and should not be mistaken for an underlying improvement.

The cycle and the automatic stabiliser

In addition to financing government spending, taxes have a major effect on economic activity.
	They also have an important automatic stabilising influence. The government tax take increases and helps to moderate consumer demand when more people are earning and spending more at the top of the economic cycle. Similarly, the tax take declines during recession and to some extent helps to offset falling wage incomes. The change in tax take is more than proportionate since marginal tax rates exceed average tax rates as income rises.

Progressive or regressive

Progressive taxes take a larger proportion of cash from the rich than from the poor, such as income tax where the marginal percentage rate of tax increases as income rises.

Proportional taxes take the same percentage of everyone's income, wealth or expenditure, but the rich pay a larger amount in total.

Regressive taxes take more from the poor. For example, a flat-rate tax of 200, such as Britain's controversial and shortlived poll tax, takes a greater proportion of the income of a loWer_paid worker than of a higher-paid worker.

73
6 FISCAL INDICATORS

Direct or indirect

Direct taxes. These are levied directly on people or companies. They include taxes on personal and corporate income, capital gains, capital transfers, inheritances and wealth; and royalties on mineral extraction.
	Direct taxes are usually charged at percentage rates; frequently they are progressive. Payroll taxes tend to be regressive if considered separately from the associated social security benefits.
	As mentioned in the previous brief, social security payments are mostly financed by specific employers' and employees' contributions. Where these are passed through a separate social security budget, "headline" revenue figures are lower. On the other hand, Denmark's social security bill is mainly met from general taxation, which depresses the apparent level of social security revenues.

Indirect taxes. Levied on goods and services, these include:

 Value-added tax (VAT) charged on the value added at each
stage of production; this amounts to a single tax on the final sale price.
 Sales and turnover taxes which may be levied on every trans-
action (for example, wheat, flour, bread) and cumulate as a product is made.
 Customs duties on imports.
 Excise duties on home-produced goods, sometimes at penal
rates to discourage activities such as smoking.

Indirect taxes tend to be regressive, as poorer people spend a bigger slice of their income. They are charged at either flat or percentage rates. Flat-rate duties do not rise with inflation and have to be "revalorised", usually in the annual budget, if the government is to retain its real tax-take.
	GDP at market prices includes indirect taxes, which increase selling prices and have to be subtracted as part of the adjustment to a factor cost basis (see pages 34-35).

Monthly figures

As with spending figures, revenues are usually published monthly in nominal values. Erratic movements can be smoothed out by taking several months together. They can be converted into real terms using the same deflator that is used for public expenditure.
	When comparing revenues against budget projections, remember that revenues will tend to be below expectation if the eco~ nomy grows more slowly than forecast.

7~

BUDGET BALANCE, DEFICIT, SURPLUS

BEGET BALANCE, DEFICIT, SURPLUS

Measures:		month/year.
lf government spending less revenues in one

Significance: Indicator of government's fiscal stance. Presented as: Monthly and annual totals in current prices.
Focus on:		Totals; trends.
Yardstick:		The average OECD deficit was 3.4% of GDP during the 1980s
	and 3.6% in 1995.
Released:		Monthly, at least one month in arrears.

Overview

Balanced budgets (revenues equal spending) sound prudent but may not always be in the best interests of economic management. Perfect balance is hard to achieve anyway, because of the automatic stabilisers in spending and revenue.

Budget deficits (spending exceeds revenues) boost total demand and output through a net injection to the circular flow of incomes. As with personal finances, a deficit on current spending may signal imprudence. However, a deficit to finance capital investment expenditure helps to lay the basis for future output and can be sustained so long as there are private or foreign savings willing to finance it in a non-inflationary way.
	Deficits are more common than surpluses. In the 1970s and early 1980s many DECD governments went on a borrowing binge, often with adverse consequences. High levels of government borrowing tend to push up interest rates and so may crowd out private-sector investment. The average budget deficit of OECD countries crept up in the early 1990s. However, after peaking at 4.3% of GDP in 1993 it fell to only 0.9% in 1998 (see Table 6.2). In that year, 11 of the 29 countries in the OECD ran a surplus. Helped by strong economic growth, America's deficit of 4.4% of GDP in 1992 became a surplus of 1.7% in 1998. Several European countries tightened their budgetary policies in order to meet the criteria to join the euro. Sweden, which is not yet a euro 1998ber, turned a 12.3% deficit in 1993 into a 1.9% surplus in

	The biggest deficit in absolute terms is that of Japan. Having had a surplus of nearly 3% of GDP in the early 1990s, Japan had a deficit of 6% of GDP, or X30 trillion ($230 billion), in 1998.

Budget surpluses (revenues exceed expenditure) may be prudent if a government is building up a large surplus on its social security fund in order to meet an expected increase in its future
6 FISCAL INDICATORS

pensions bill as the population ages. However, a surplus may be undesirable if it takes too much money out of the circular flow.
	The world's largest relative budget surpluses (20-30% of GDP) have been run by Kuwait prior to the 1990 Iraqi invasion and Botswana, as a result of income from the sale of oil and diamonds respectively. The receipts come from foreigners rather than the domestic circular flow, so the surpluses manage to stimulate even though they appear deflationary. Other countries' surpluses tend to be smaller, typically up to 5% of GDP.

Tighter or looser. Fiscal policy is said to have tightened if a deficit is reduced or converted into a surplus or if a surplus is increased, after taking into account the effects of the economic cycle. A move in the opposite direction is called a loosening of fiscal policy.

The cycle and the automatic stabiliser

There is an automatic stabiliser built into the budget balance. Surpluses reduce or tip into the red and deficits grow during a recession when tax revenues fall and welfare spending increases. This helps to maintain aggregate demand. The opposite happens during an economic boom.
	The cyclically adjusted budget balance is the normal balance with cyclical fluctuations removed. This helps to identify the underlying fiscal stance, but such figures should always be regarded with suspicion because it is difficult to get the adjustments right.

Definitions

There are three main ways of looking at the budget balance. One is the published "headline" balance which depends on national definitions and accounting practices. The other two are the borrowing requirement and net savings, both of which are usually tricky to identify precisely from published figures.

The borrowing requirement. The net total of government spending less revenues is the gap which has to be financed by borrowing or which allows debt to be repaid. The announced budget balance in Britain used to be exactly this figure: the public-sector borrowing requirement (PSBR), or for surpluses the public-sector debt repayment (PSDR). However, the PssR (now renamed the public-sector net cash requirement) has now been' downgraded in favour of the "current balance" (see below).
	In most countries the precise definition varies depending

BUDGET BALANCE, DEFICIT, SURPLUS

,hat is included in "the budget". There are two important areas to consider.

Level of government. Headline budget figures for North America are for federal government only and for France cover just central government. At the other extreme, those for Germany cover federal, Under and local authorities, and Switzerland's include federal, confederations, cantons and local government.

On or off budget. Many government activities fall outside the normal budget, including lending by government agencies and government farm crop or export insurance, as well as government-guaranteed borrowing by publicly owned enterprises and government-guaranteed lending by private sector bodies. Two other specific examples worthy of note are the American savings and loan rescue plan which was expected to cost over $100 billion in 1991-96, and the German Treuhand agency, which among other things was authorised to borrow DM25 billion (about $15 billion) in 1990-91 to help to restructure and privatise east German industry.

Net savings. The balance of current spending and receipts indicates the public sector's net savings; the extent to which the public sector is adding to or subtracting from the circular flow of incomes. This differs from the budget balance in that it includes only current, not capital, transactions. Britain's "current balance" corresponds to the government's net savings.

Figure 6.2

Budget balances

	of GDP, 1998
4
Z		1.9
0		_

~e
-2		S'~

swa: ec.

1.7 ~ e~a~

1.3							1.0	0.5	0.4	v
				# e~ e`\aC4,~'~a~ OeW~ ~J~'' ~Qxc ~e~a ~PO4~a \a			~~ac

JSPaaa							,etw	x~a
	sac							Qec~c PJ~y	.0.7	_0.9	_1.3 	''

-1.6				_1 .8	_Z.0 	.Z.t

-2.7		-7.9
6 FISCAL INDICATORS

Monthly figures and targets

Budget balances are usually published monthly in nominal values. Erratic movements can be smoothed by taking several months together. They can be converted into real terms by deflating spending and revenue separately.
	When comparing cumulative budget balances with projections, remember that deficits tend to expand if the economy grows more slowly than forecast.

Table 6.2 General government budget balances

of GDP

				Net public
1985				1990	1995	1998	debt,1998

Australia			-2.8	0.4	-3.4	0.5	16.6
Austria			-2.6	-2.4	-5.1	-2.1	43.9
Belgium			-9.1	-5.4	-3.9	-1.3	112.5
Denmark			...	-1.0	-2.3	1.0	35.8
France			-2.9	-1.6	-4.9	-2.9	43.6
Germany			-1.2	-2.1	-3.3	-2.0	47.6
Italy			-12.4	-11.2	-7.7	-2.7	107.5
Japan			-0.8	2.9	-3.6	-6.0	29.9
Netherlands				-3.6	-5.1	-3.7	-0.7	53.3
Spain			-5.8	-4.3	-7.3	-1.8	53.4
Sweden			-3.8	4.2	-7.0	1.9	15.3
UK			-2.9	-1.5	-5.8	0.4	42.1
USA			-3.2	-2.7	-1.9	1.7	41.2
HU15			-4.8	-3.9	-5.3	-1.6	57.1
DECD			-3.4	-2.1	-3.4	-0.9	43.6

	Source: DECD.

NATIONAL DEBTS GOVERNMENT OR PUBLIC DEBT

Measures:		Long-run cumulative total of government spending less
	revenues.
Significance:		Inter-generational transfer, interest payments add to borrowing.
Presented as:		Annual totals in current prices.
Focus on:		Total, particularly as a percentage of GDP; trends.
Yardstick:		Varies widely; see text
Released:		Mainly annually; not easily found.

Overview

The public or national debt is the cumulative total of all governs
ment borrowing less repayments. It is financed mainly by citizen

NATIONAL DEBT; GOVERNMENT OR PUBLIC DEBT

and may be seen as a transfer between generations. This contrasts with external debt (see page 138) which has to be financed out of export earnings.

Size of debt
Figure 6.3 shows the relative size of various national debts in 1998. Belgium and Italy headed the list with debt that was greater than their annual GDP.
	The debt is often understated since governments carry various liabilities which do not show on their balance sheets. For example, public-sector pensions are usually unfunded, that is, paid out of current income rather than from a reserve created during the individual's working life as happens with private-sector pensions.
	Economic theory provides few clues to the optimum ratio of public debt to GDP. Trends over time are often a better measure of a government's creditworthiness than the absolute level of debt. A country with an ever-rising debt ratio is clearly heading for trouble.

Figure 6.3

Net public debt

of GDP, 1998

1so

z.s

100 -

so a

Source: DECD.
