CONSUMERS

"Live within your income, even if you have to borrow money
to do so."
Josh Billings

Overview

Consumers are important since personal consumption accounts for between half and two-thirds of GDP.

In general, if consumers' incomes increase (perhaps because of wage rises or tax cuts) they will save some and spend the rest. The part which is spent becomes income for someone else, who in turn spends and saves. The process is repeated and the multiplier effect makes everyone better off, provided that the growth in spending goes into extra production rather than higher prices.

At the same time, the proportion of consumers' income that is saved provides the finance for investment, which is essential for future production, income and consumption.

Consumers, persons and households

For the most part, economic analysis is most effective if focused on a clearly defined group of economic agents, such as households. However, national accounting practices vary and figures are not generally available for such neat units. Terminology can become cloudy.

 Household. A group of people living under one roof and

sharing cooking facilities.

 Consumer sector and personal sector. These terms are gen

erally used interchangeably and are usually defined to include:
households and individuals; owners of unincorporated busi
nesses; non-profit-making bodies serving individuals; private
trusts; and private pension, life assurance and welfare funds
Private Private consumption. The same as personal consumption
since, by national accounts definition, companies do nt
consume. But businesses invest, so private (personal Plus

80

PERSONAL INCOME, DISPOSABLE INCOME

business) investment is different from personal investment.

Total consumption. Personal (private) consumption plus government consumption.

PERSONAL INCOME, DISPOSABLE INCOME

Measures:		Personal sector total income and income after tax.
Significance:		Basis for consumption and savings.
Presented as:		Money totals.
Focus on: 		Growth rates.

Yardstick: 3% a year in real terms. Released: Mainly quarterly, monthly in USA; I-3 months in arrears.

Personal income is current income received by the personal sector from all sources. The bulk is wages and salaries, but the total also covers rents (including the imputed rental value to owner-occupiers of their homes), interest and dividends (including those received by life assurance and pension funds), and current transfers such as social security benefits paid to persons and business donations to charities.

Personal disposable income (PDI). Personal income after the deduction of personal direct taxes and fees (such as passport fees), and current transfers abroad. The figures in Table 7.1 give an indication of the composition of income and disposable income.

Real personal income and PDI. Personal incomes and personal disposable income are occasionally quoted in nominal terms, that is, before allowing for inflation. Real personal income and real PD, are incomes adjusted for inflation. Consumer prices can be used if no other deflator is available. Loosely, if incomes rise by 5% and prices increase by 3%, real incomes are 2% higher.

International comparisons

International comparisons are affected by differences in the provision or treatment of private pensions, life insurance, social securItY3 household interest payments, and current and capital transfers.

In general PDI is reasonably consistent internationally, but personal income is less so. For example, British personal income includes employers' social security contributions and excludes employees' contributions. Both sets of contributions are deducted frm personal income to arrive at PDI. In America social insurance payments are excluded from both total income and disposable

81






7 CONSUMERS

Table 7.1 Personal income, outlays and savings in the United States, 1998 $bn

Wages and salaries of which: Productive enterprises Distribution Services Government Other labour income Proprietors' income of which: Faun Non-farm Rental income Interest income Dividends Transfers Less social insurance contributions Less taxes etc Personal disposable income (PDI) Total deductions of which: Personal consumption Interest payments Transfers overseas Personal savings Savings ratio (savings as % of PDI)

Source: US Department of Commerce.

4,186.0

1,038.7
	944.6
1,509.9
	692.8
	515.7
	606.1

		25.1
	581.0
	137.4
	897.8
	348.3
	983.6
	-315.9
-1,072.6
6,286.2
6,056.6

5,848.6
	185.7
	22.3
	229.7
		3.7

income. Thus British personal income is inflated slightly relative to that in America, but PDI is on the same social security basis in both countries.
	Similarly, personal receipts. In America income includes interest received on savings but interest paid on loans is treated as part of expenditure. In this case American income and PDI are both inflated relative to Britain's.

income in Britain includes net interest

Interpretation

Incomes are affected by the economic cycle. In general it is advisable to look for sustainable growth in real incomes - t rapid an increase may be inflationary (see Chapter 13). The main components are as follows.

Income from employment. The major influence on personal income. The total depends mainly on the number of people

82

CONSUMER EXPENDITURE AND CONSUMPTION

employment, hours

Chapter 13).

worked (see Chapter 5) and their pay (see

Income from self-employment. The next most important component of PDI. Self-employed incomes are linked to the general health f the economy. They will increase when nominal GDP rises.

Interest and dividends. Dividends are sensitive to company profits and the state of the economy, while interest payments obviously move in line with interest rates. When borrowing is high relative to savings, an increase in interest rates can mean a fall in net interest income. Generally an increase in interest rates boosts PDI because in most countries (Britain is the main exception) the personal sector has more assets with adjustable interest rates than liabilities.

Taxes and benefits. Changes in the rates of tax or benefits have a rapid effect on PDI (but not, of course, on personal income). The magnitude will depend on the nature of the change; see Chapter 6.

CONSUMER AND PERSONAL EXPENDITURE PRIVATE CONSUMPTION

Measures: Spending by persons. Significance: Key component of GDP. Presented as: Money totals.

Focus on:		Growth rates.
Yardstick:		The OECD average growth in consumer expenditure was
	2.8% a year during the 1980s and 1.7% during the period
	1990-95.
	Quarterly with GAP figures, monthly in USA; frequently
	revised.
Overview

consumer expenditure is personal (mainly household) spending n goods and services. Thus it includes imputed rents on ownerccupied dwellings; the outlays which would be required to buy income in kind; and administrative costs of life assurance and Pension funds. It excludes interest payments; the purchase of land and buildings; transfers abroad; all business expenditure;

and spending on second-hand goods, which reflects a transfer of nership rather than new production.

Released:

83
7 CONSUMERS

	Strictly speaking, expenditure takes place when goods are per., chased, while consumption may take place over several years. For example, the benefit derived from a car or television is enjoyed (consumed) over several years. In practice it is hard to measure consumption and the term is used loosely to mean expenditure. Thus consumer expenditure, personal expenditure and private consumption are all the same thing.

Significance

84

Spending by consumers accounts for between half and twothirds of GDP. Arithmetically a 1/D rise in consumer expenditure contributes to around a 0.6/D increase in total GDP all else being equal, which it rarely is of course. In particular some of the extra consumer spending will go into higher imports.

Spending decisions

Personal income is either spent or saved. Decisions about consumption are intertwined with decisions about savings (see next brief).
	The best guesses at what determines spending and saving are the broadly similar "permanent-income hypothesis" and "lifecycle hypothesis", which suggest that consumption is linked to income over a lifetime. Young and old households have a high propensity to spend their income, while those in mid-life save for retirement. In addition, households tend to run down savings or borrow to maintain consumption during a recession (spreading spending over their lifetimes).
	Major influences on the level of consumption include the following.

Incomes. In general higher personal incomes allow more spending.
Price expectations. Experience shows that consumers tend to save more (and spend less) during periods of high inflation (see next brief). They may bring spending forward, however, if they expect a one-off increase in prices because of inflation or higher indirect (sales) taxes.
Interest rates. Higher interest rates push up the cost of existing loans and discourage borrowing and, perhaps, encourage savings, all of which depress spending. Nevertheless higher interest rates also redistribute income from young mortgage payers to their elders whose deposits are greater than their borrowings and who may spend their additional interest income
		Consumer credit. Easier consumer credit may encourage
	borrowing, which translates directly into higher spending.

CONSUMER EXPENDTI'tJRE AND CONSUMPTION

Wealth. A rise in asset values, such as share or house prices, may make consumers feel wealthier and inclined to spend more. Stock level and price of durables. Consumers tend to regard durables such as cars and electrical appliances as wealth. A sudden end to a period of restricted supply of durables as in eastern Germany in 1990, or a fall in their prices, may encourage a temporary consumer boom. This may set up replacement cycles, with bouts of spending on durables every few years.
Social factors. These may encourage saving to allow bequests or retirement spending.

Figure 7.1

Consumer spending
% of GDP, 1997

Source: DECD.

60		60

J- ~awa 4.L0									ac	cve	av1	aca	J~h	ac	cas 	as
	Pub`					O	SQ	~~a	t~ see

5~

Figure 7.2

Growth in real consumer spending
Annual average "/o change, 1993-98

s.o

4.3

4.0

3.0
z.o
to
o.o

a.o
7 CONSUMERS

Table 7.2 Consumer spending

/. of GDP		Real annual % chan e
1985				1997	1979-84 1985-94	1995	1998
.

Australia			60	63	3.5	2.7	4.2	4.3
Austria			57	57	2.4	2.4	1.9	1.8 ;,
Belgium			...	63	13.0	2.2	1.4	3
Canada			58	58	2.5	2.2	1.4	2 ~ f
Denmark			54	50	0.3	1.5	2.3	3.5 :
France			60	61	1.2	2.0	1.8	3.8
Germany			57	58	1.2	2.9	1.7	1.9
Italy		63		61	1.8	2.2	1.6	1.9
Japan			59	60	1.9	3.0	1.6	-1.1
Netherlands			60	60	0.1	2.2	2.1	4.5
Spain			63	62	0.2	2.7	1.8	3,8
Sweden			52	52	0.3	0.9	0.3	2.6
Switzerland			62	61	1.5	1.2	0.2	1.8
UK		59		64	2.4	2.6	2.3	2.7
USA		65		68	2.9	2.3	2.4	4.9
EU15		58		60	1.9	2.6	1.8	2.9
DECD			62	62	2.7	2.5	1.8	2.8

Source: OECD; World Bank.

The cycle

There is a cyclical pattern in consumer expenditure. The most volatile component is spending on durables: goods with a life of over one year such as washing machines, furniture and cars.
	When economic conditions are tight, spending on durables can be cut more readily than spending on non-durables such as food and heating. Thus there is a stable core of spending on nondurables, and a fluctuating level of spending on durables which moves in line with the economic cycle.

International comparisons

Total spending is affected by the level of services provided by the state. For example, in Belgium and France where health care is initially paid for by the user, the outlays are included in consumer expenditure. Where health services are more or less free at the point of use, as in Britain and Nordic countries, no entry appears under consumer spending. In developing countries $ greater proportion of spending is on essentials such as food.

Interpretation

The focus should be on real percentage change. Some countr'es'

86

PERSONAL AND HOUSEHOLD SAVINGS; SAVINGS RATIO

such as America, publish monthly figures in nominal terms, Which may be deflated by consumer prices to obtain a feel for the real growth. For example, if nominal personal spending groWS by 6% and consumer prices rise by 4%, spending has risen by about 2% in real terms. Changes in spending on durables can be an early signal of developments.
	Retail sales (page 117), car sales (page 111) and consumer confidence (page 89) also provide leading indicators of spending patterns.

PERSONAL AND HOUSEHOLD SAVINGS; SAVINGS

RATIO

Measures: Savings by households. Significance: Key component of total national savings. Presented as: Money totals and as a percentage of disposable income.
Focus on:		Trends.
Yardstick:		The OECD average savings ratio was about 10.3% during
	the 1980s.
Released:		Quarterly or annually; frequently revised.

Overview

Personal savings, an important chunk of national savings (see page 98), are personal disposable income less personal consumption. Many governments also produce savings data for households alone. The household savings ratio is household savings as a percentage of household disposable income.

	The household or personal sector's financial deficit or surplus (the net balance of deposits and loans) is different from savings. For this reason consumer borrowing - which influences spending and saving - can be considered separately (see page 84).

International comparisons

Household savings ratios are shown with national savings in Table 8.3. Household savings ratios vary widely between countries. For example, in 1998 net household savings were 0.5% of household income in America and 13.6% in Japan (see Figure ~~3). There are a number of reasons for this.
	As far as definitions are concerned, the calculations depend on t"e treatment of consumer durables, private pensions and life insurance Payments, social security, household interest payments, capital transfers and depreciation. Adjusting for such factors reduces the gap between Japan's and America's savings ratios by nd 3 percentage Doints.
7 CONSUMERS

Figure 7.3

Net household savings
% of disposable household income, 1998

,1.6			1,.5	11 .0 --E ^ ~ 10.5

7.8 j 5.8

111_1114.z
.

`a~ laQao							c~a	~avi	~1	c	`a~a	~a	Ji-	ate
	C9				~ca~	`~ `,yep	P~	P,Jt~c~	gas
t

Source: DECD.

	Other factors which account for a large part of the remaining difference between the Japanese and American ratios include the age structure of the population and the labour force; the distribution of incomes; the availability of consumer credit; the tax treatment of savings; the social security system; and economic variables such as those discussed below.

Influences on household savings

The experience of the industrial countries in recent decades highlights some factors which affect savings. Note that savings appear to be relatively unaffected by changes in interest rates.
The 1970s. Economists were confounded by the rise in savings which accompanied the high inflation of the 1970s. Theory said that with falling real disposable incomes and negative real interest rates the savings ratio should have fallen. It seems that households save more during high inflation in order to maintain the real value of their savings.
The 1980s. Savings ratios fell in the 1980s for several reasons There was lower inflation; stockmarkets were rising; in some countries higher house prices boosted personal wealth and s encouraged spending; financial liberalisation made borrowW easier; public pensions improved; and the population was ageing (older people save less).
The 1990s. Perhaps the most striking feature of savings trends 0 the 1990s was the continuing fall in America's already low hogi hold savings rates. On some estimates, this figure turned 11192>w in 1999 - ie American households' expenditure exceeded 14

CONSUMER CONFIDENCE

incomes One reason may be that Americans felt wealthier because of tile rise in the stockmarket. Or prolonged economic growth may have made them more optimistic about future earnings.

Interpretation

See National savings, page 98, for hints on interpretation. Note that the ageing population (see Population, page 57) is likely to reduce savings rates in Japan and Europe in the 1990s and in North America in the next century.

CONSUMER CONFIDENCE

Measures:		Consumers' perception of their economic well-being.
Significance:		Determines short-term spending/borrowing/savings plans.
Presented as:		Usually index numbers.
Focus on:		Trends.
Yardstick:		Watch for changes in direction.
Released: 		Monthly, one month in arrears.

Overview

Survey evidence of consumer perceptions is indicator. In general, the more optimistic

valuable as a leading consumers are, the more likely they are to spend money. This boosts consumer spending and economic output.
	Surveys of consumer confidence are conducted by private sector organisations such as the Conference Board in America and Gallup in Britain. The results are presented in index form or as percentage balances (of consumers feeling more optimistic less those feeling less optimistic).

Other indicators

Other popular indicators of consumer confidence include:

* The misery index I. The rate of consumer-price inflation plus
the unemployment rate.
" The misery index II. The rate of consumer-price inflation plus
annual interest rates.

	each case the higher the number, the more miserable
	consumers are assumed to be. However, once inflation falls
	Palling prices can haute damaging economic effectss e misery index becomes les meaning-
Q,
