INVESTMENT AND SAVINGS

"Saving is a very fine thing. Especially when your parents have
done it for you."
Sir Winston Churchill

Overview

Investment deserves special attention because it is so important for the future health of an economy. It lays the basis for future production.

Investment is spending on physical assets with a life of more than one year. This should be distinguished from financial transactions which are known as investment in everyday language but which are - from an economic viewpoint - savings.

It is conventional to say that businesses invest while individuals consume. If a household buys itself a personal computer, this is recorded in the national accounts as personal consumption. If a business buys the same model, the spending is classed as investment. The rationale is that the household uses a PC for "pleasure" while a business uses it in the production of future output. A company's stocks of raw materials and goods are classed as investment.

The circular flow of incomes

Chapter 4 (page 39) outlined the concept of the circular flow of incomes. Savings and investment are perhaps the most important leakage and injection. It is easiest to understand their significance through an example.

Imagine a simple system in which firms produce $100m of goods a year. Suppose that households save $20m. Output

$100m, incomes are $100m, and consumption is $80m. Since the firms sell only $80m of their output, the remainder is left 10 stock at the end of the year. The $20m increase in stocks is classed as investment spending. In order to meet their wage b>1% the firms have to borrow $20m from the banks where the house' holds saved their $20m. Output is $100m, incomes are $10001'

90

Total investment/saving

NW Totals may not equal the sum Source: IMF.

World Saving Investment Total investment/saving industrial countries

private saving

Government saving private investment

Government investment Total investment/saving USA

private saving

Government saving Private investment

Government investment Total investment/saving EU

Private saving

Government saving Private investment

Government investment Total investment/saving Japan

Private saving

Government saving Private investment

Government investment Total investment/saving Developing countries

Saving
Investment

Table 8.1 Investment and savings

% Of GDP

THE CIRCULAR FLOW OF INCOMES

22.8				22.0	23.2	22.8
23.6				23.5	23.8	23.0
46.4				45.5	47.0	45.8

19.7
1.3
17.5

3.9

42.4

19.8
0.1
16.0
4.1
40.0

20.2 0.8

16.9 3.9

41.8

18.3

2.9

17.1

3.6

41.9

	15.8				14.9	15.2	12.4
	0.6				-0.5	1.1	4.3
	14.9				13.4	14.4	16.1
	3.5				3.1	3.0	2.8
	34.8				30.9	33.7	35.6
	21.6				21.5	22.4	20.0
	-0.3				-2.9	-2.3	0.7
	17.7				15.3	16.7	17.1
	3.2				3.1	2.7	2.6
	42.2				37.0	39.5	40.4

25.1
7.8
23.4
6.8
63.1

34.9
28.7
63.6

	25.8			25.9	27.4
	6.9			4.9	2.3
	21.1			20.0	18.6
	8.6			8.6	7.9
	62.4			59.4	56.2

33.4
31.0
64.4

33.4
32.4
65.8

of components owing to rounding.

34.5
25.3
59.8

and total spending is $80m consumption plus $20m investment which equals $1 OOm.

The leakage of $20m for saving is matched by an injection of $ZOm for investment. Investment (in stocks or fixed assets) can

take Place only when some consumption is deferred. By defini~ ' investment - savings.

t1i O mount that househoCourse there is no lds wish t mechanism matches hthe amount that

G











H INVESTMENT AND SAVINGS

firms wish to invest. Investment and savings are each determined by different factors which are discussed in the following briefs.

Economic effects of imbalance. Loosely, if planned savings exceed planned investment, stocks pile up and companies cut back their production: GDP falls. If planned savings are less than planned investment, companies produce more to meet the extra demand and GDP rises. (See Cyclical indicators, page 51.)

The golden rule. It is difficult to identify the ideal level of saving and investment. Less saving means more consumption today but less investment and so less future consumption. Economists talk about the "golden rule" which maximises the consumption per head of all generations. Significantly, an IMF study suggests that America's national savings in the period 1986-90 were only half the amount required by the golden rule.

National savings and investment. All sectors of the economy save and invest. Real life is not as simple as business investment and household savings. Table 8.1 shows flows of funds around the world. The following briefs discuss the topics in more detail.

FIXED INVESTMENT AND GDFCF

Measures: Spending on goods with a life of more than one year. . Significance: Contributes directly to GDP, lays basis for future output Presented as: Value, volume and index numbers.
Focus on:		Volume trend.
Yardstick:		OECD average fixed investment grew by 3.2% a year durirt
	the 1980s and by 2.0% a year during the period 1990-97
Released:		Quarterly, I-3 months in arrears; frequently revised.

Overview

Fixed investment is spending on physical assets. Total investment is fixed investment plus investment in stocks of raw materials and goods (see Stocks, page 96).
	Physical assets include infrastructure such as roads and docks; buildings such as dwellings, factories and offices; plant and machinery; vehicles; and equipment such as computers. T'esc generally provide the potential for higher output in the future The economic (as opposed to the social) benefit of dwellings 00 some infrastructure is more arguable, but most infrastr'u
boosts economic efficiency. For example, new roads help to

FIXED INVESTMENT AND GDFCF

delivery teams back for more work rather than crawling at lOkph through the world's congested cities.

Investment and consumption. By convention, only businesses invest. All personal spending is consumption for national accounts purposes, except the purchase of new dwellings. These have such a long life that they are classed as investment. Most government spending, including that on defence equipment, is classified as consumption (see pages 31-32).

GDFCF. Economists pompously call new investment in physical assets "gross domestic fixed capital formation". Gross because it is before depreciation; domestic because it is at home rather than overseas; fixed because it does not include stocks; and capital formation since it distinguishes physical from financial investment.
	Fixed investment is rarely shown net because of the problem of accounting for capital retirements and obsolescence.

Interpretation

Fixed investment accounts for an average of around 20% of GDP in industrial economies. So as a crude rule of thumb, a 1% rise in fixed investment adds around 0.2% to GDP in the same period, all else being constant.
	The potential for future output will also be boosted (see Productivity, pages 49-51), especially by investment in plant and machinery. Table 8.2 shows that this is typically 7-9% of GDP.
	The direct relationship between investment and output is complex. Investment is shown gross and the increase in productive capacity will be less after allowing for depreciation, and so on, but in developing countries at least, a given change in investment this year can be used as the basis for a moderately reliable forecast of the change in GDP next year.

The cycle. Investment is highly cyclical. Firms are more likely to invest if they are operating at a high level of capacity, if they expect demand to remain high and if interest rates are low. (See Business conditions and Capacity use, pages 103 and 107.) teen these conditions are reversed, businesses are likely to cut back on fixed investment. However, investment projects have 1ng lead times and a cut in new investment does not automaticavy Imply a fall in total investment spending.
A I % increase in demand may be translated into a greater than 1
~Icrease in output if firms respond by increasing investment spend~(See "accelerator principle" in Cyclical indicators, page 51.)
8 INVESTMENT AND SAVINGS

Figure 8.1

Fixed investment
of GDP, 7997

35

30

25

20

15

cA				(.O	ac a a
		5e P3a
.x

Source: OECD.

Table 8.2 Fixed investment

'/o of GDP, 1995

Machinery Construction		Annual % change
	&		non- resid
equipment res'1 ential Other Total 1980-90 1990-97

Australia				7.5	2.9	4.9	6.5	21.8	2.7	5.4
Austria			...	...		...	...	26.8	2.2	2.6
Belgium				...	...	...	...	19.2	3.2	-0.3
Canada			6.4	6.0		4.9	0.0	17.3	5.2	1.5
Denmark				7.9	3.2	4.8	0.1	16.0	3.9	3.4
France			7.2	5.4		4.5	0.8	17.9	2.8	-2.0
Germany				7.6	14.1a	...	0.0	21.7	...	0.8
Italy			8.6	8.4a		...	0.0	17.0	1.9	-1.9
Japan			14.7	5.5		5.0	4.5	29.7	5.3	0.5
	Netherlands 8.1			5.5		5.4	1.1	20.1	3.1	0.6
Spain			7.2	14.58		...	10.0	22.7	5.7	-1.5
Sweden				...		...	...	15.5	4.4	-3.2
Switzerland				...	...	...	...	23.1	4.0	-0.9
UK			...	...		...	...	17.0	6.4	1.4
USA			8.4	4.4		3.6	1.2	17.6	2.9	5.8
EU15			...	...		...	...	19.7	...	0.0
OECD			...	...		...	...	20.6	4.1	2.0

a Commercial and residential construction combined.

Sources: OECD; World Bank.

Government intervention. Government incentives for inest~
ment should be treated with caution as they can be countet't productive in the long run. Tax subsidies make poor investmco

94

INVESTMENT INTENTIONS

Figure 8.2

Growth in real fixed investment
Annual average % change, 1990-97

s~$ s.a

burce:OECD.

3.4

2. 6
	2,0
		1.5 1.4

0.8			0.6	0.5
F771 F-7,11 0.0

o
		aaa														J'~ 	ac9	cJ5	ac	J~5	of	ca	ao	vi	va
O																IF	eee rata	laQ	`~ 0yv ~~ea~a	SQ	~ 'aac
b

projects viable.
	Changes in government investment spending should also be scrutinised. In more mature economies government expenditure can crowd out private-sector investment with detrimental effects, but in developing countries public and private investment are often complementary.

Other indicators. GDP investment figures are released with a lag. Other indicators should be used for advance signals, especially investment intentions, construction spending, housing starts, auto sales, manufacturing production and imports of capital goods.

Sectoral. Investment is classified by ownership rather than enduse. Sectoral investment figures should not be taken at face value. Investment by service companies may reflect spending on goods which are subsequently leased to industrial firms.

INVESTMENT INTENTIONS
Measures: Significance: Presented as: Focus on: Yardstick: Released:

Plans for capital spending, sometimes just in manufacturing. Investment adds to current and future GDP. Value, volume totals or changes. Trend: planned volume increases. Look for planned increases of several percentage points. Monthly, one month in arrears.

95
8 INVESTMENT AND SAVINGS

Governments and trade associations such as the US Nation Association of Purchasing Managers and the Confederation of British Industry publish the results of surveys of investment intentions. These may be wholly subjective ("Do you expect more or fewer capital authorisations over the next 12 monthsy) or misleadingly quantitative ("How many dollars' worth of capi_ tal spending will you undertake in the calendar year?"). See also Business conditions, page 103.

Value and volume

Where surveys are in value terms, the first step should be to consider how closely the figures relate to volumes. Respondents tend to indicate the value of investment after allowing for any expected price increases, so the totals should be deflated to arrive at the planned volume increase. As a crude deflator use producer prices. If these are rising by 5% and companies expect the value of their investment to increase by 7%, the volume of investment will be about 2% greater. If inflation is accelerating or decelerating, use the consensus view (at the time of the survey) of expected inflation for the period ahead.

Outcomes

Intentions are rarely turned into spending on a one-for-one basis. Investment intentions surveys tell you something about future trends in the economy, but at the same time you should interpret the survey results in the light of developments in the economy. For example, a rise in interest rates after a survey may lead to a lower than announced level of investment.

STOCKS (INVENTORIES)

Measures: Stocks held by producers and distributors. Significance: Indicator of demand pressures; potential sales. Presented as: Value and volume totals and changes.
Focus on:		Totals in relation to sales, changes.
Yardstick:		See text.
Released:		Quarterly, sometimes monthly, 1-3 months in arre,'
	frequently revised.

96

STOCKS (INVENTORIES)

overview
Stocks or inventories are materials and fuel, work-in-progress and finished goods held by companies.
The book value of stocks changes for two reasons.

Stock appreciation is an increase in the money value of stocks
owing to inflation. It adds to nominal income (the inventories can be sold at a profit) but there is no addition to real output. . Stockbuilding (or destocking) is a change in the physical vol-
ume of inventories. It reflects the production of goods and affects nominal and real output.

	Data are generally collected in value terms and deflated into volume terms using assumptions about accounting practices, stockholding patterns and price changes. The breakdown between the physical change and stock appreciation can be unreliable, especially during periods of rapid inflation.

Cycles

In general the level of stocks rises as national income increases, but there are wide fluctuations which reflect the economic cycle.
	Stocks are a buffer between production and consumption. When demand increases unexpectedly, the first sign is a decrease in inventories before manufacturers can respond by increasing output. Alternatively, if an increase in demand is expected, stocks may be built up in advance ready to meet the extra demand. Either way, production can increase faster than demand for short periods during restocking or stockbuilding.
	Stocks accumulate when demand turns down unexpectedly; production might fall faster than sales as excess stocks are consumed.

Inflation. Stocks of raw materials react violently to expected changes in world commodity prices (see also page 191).

Interpretation

The stocksaales ratios at each stage of activity (manufacturing, wholesaling, retailing) are important leading indicators.
	If the ratios are higher than normal (look at a long run of figures), this implies that production and imports will be cut unless demand increases. If the ratios are lower than normal the impligat'n is that production and imports will rise unless demand falls (but note that stock ratios fell sharply in the industrial coun-

97
H INVESTMENT AND SAVINGS

tries during the 1980s because of better stock control techniques such as just-in-time). If the ratios are low and there are capacity constraints (high capacity utilisation and/or low unemployment), the excess demand might go into higher inflation or imports.

	High or low stocksaales ratios all the way through the economy give fairly clear signals. Different ratios at different stages imply bottlenecks or structural problems. For example, a low ratio in retailing and a high ratio in manufacturing may indicate that an increase in consumer demand has not yet fed through to manufacturers, or it might suggest that domestic producers cannot provide the required goods and the excess consumer demand is going into imports.
	Surveys (see Business conditions, page 103) provide useful evidence about companies' perceptions of their stocks. If, say, manufacturers think that their stocks are too high, they will cut production over the next few months unless demand increases.

GDP

It is not the total level of stocks but the change in the rate of stockbuilding which affects the GDP expenditure measure. An increase in stocks reflects extra output that has not been consumed. Note, however, that a fall in the level of stocks can lead to an increase in GDP if the rate of destocking slows.
	The effects of changes in stocks are limited when measured over several years, but stockbuilding is highly volatile quarter-by-

quarter. Accordingly, changes in the rate of stockbuilding can be a major influence on demand and GDP. The snag is that stockbuilding is the trickiest component of GDP to forecast.

NATIONAL SAVINGS, SAVINGS RATIO

Measures: Total savings in an economy. Significance: Major influence on investment and interest rates. Presented as: Totals; percentage of GDP.
Focus on:		Trends.
Yardstick:		The OECD average was 21 % during the 1980s and 20.2%
	the early 1990s.
Released:		Quarterly with GDP figures. Total savings = investment

Overview

Savings (deferred consumption) affect investment (the basis for future output and consumption). For the economy as a whole it"' the national savings rate which is important: the sum of savings by

98

NATIONAL SAVINGS, SAVINGS RATIO

the private sector and the government.
	Gross savings are the savings required to finance gross investment. Net savings are those required to finance investment net of capital consumption. The national savings ratio is savings as a percentage of GDP.

private savings

private savings are the sum of savings by persons and companies. (See also Personal savings, page 86.) Company savings are cyclical since businesses hold liquid reserves to cushion themselves against the economic cycle and to provide funds for expansion.

Government savings

Government savings are general government revenue less current expenditure. Government capital spending is classed as investment. Thus although the budget balance is often taken as a proxy for government savings, there can be a large difference between the two (amounting to, for example, 5.0% of GDP for Italy during the early 1990s).
Government savings or, frequently, dissavings reflect political

decisions and are largely cyclical. Budget cuts in the industrial countries have led to higher government savings or lower government dissavings as a percentage of GDP in several OECD countries in the 1990s.

National savings and the investment gap

A net inflow of foreign capital implies that domestic savings are

less than domestic investment: foreigners' excess savings fill the gap. A net outflow of capital implies that domestic savings are bigger man domestic investment. Net foreign savings are conveniently defined as the balance on the current account of the balance of payments with the sign reversed (see Current account, page 133).
Current-account deficits indicate the extent to which domestic

investment is financed by foreign savings. For example, the American current-account deficit (averaging 1.4% of GIMP in 1990-95) represented a net inflow of foreign savings of the same proportion.

Interpretation

Trends in domestic savings are an important indicator to watch. ~e comments in this chapter suggest that an increase in domestic savings rates would be no bad thing.

	99
8 INVESTMENT AND SAVINGS

Table 8.3 Savings ratios

Householdsa		Nationalb

	1985 1990					1995	1998	1985	1990	1995	,ry7
Australia			7.3 6.8			1.3	2.5	18.9	17.3	17.6	18.4
Austria			8.3 13.7			13.4	8.6	23.2	26.3	22.4	23.p
Belgium			14.0 17.1			19.3	11.6	15.0	21.0	22.5	22.4
Canada			13.3 9.7			7.4	1.2	19.6	16.4	17.8	18.4
Denmark			... 11.4			5.4	5.8	14.9	17.8	20.4	20,9
France			14.0 12.5			14.3	14.1	18.9	21.5	19.8	20.0
Germany 11.4					13.8	11.6	11.0	22.0	24.9	20.6	20,7
Italy			18.9 18.2			13.1	11.5	21.6	19.6	20.6	20.4
Japan			15.6 12.1			13.4	13.6	31.7	34.6	30.8	31.1
Netherlands 0.1					5.8	1.8	-0.6	24.3	26.0	24.7	27.1
Spain			11.2 10.5			11.7	10.5	20.6	21.7	21.3	21.0
Sweden			2.3 -0.6			8.2	1.2	17.5	17.7	16.7	16.1
Switzerland 5.7					12.2	9.9	9.0	29.8	33.1	28.5	29.0
UK		10.7 8.1				10.2	7.8	17.6	14.3	14.3	14.9
USA			7.1 5.2			4.7	0.5	17.6	15.6	16.2	17.4
EU15			... ...			...	...	20.1	21.0	19.6	19.9
OECD			... ...			...	...	21.1	21.0	20.4	21.1

a Net household savings as % of disposable personal income.
b Gross national savings as % of GDP.

Source: DECD.

Figure 8.3

Gross national savings
% of GDP, 1997

31.1
	29.0
		27.7

23.022.4
21.1

U

40

30

zo

,o

0						J1
	ac				a	61 is	F (.O ac a~act avi cce J~h as aaa J5P ae
~aQ				aop ~1ac Pte`'` ~yA	04'	SQ 466 ~e~F ~ ya	~, PJy~ 	`ac	ys~

S`

Source: OECD.

21.0 20.9 20.7 20.4 20.019.9

INDUSTRY AND COMMERCE

"If economists were any good at business, they would be rich men
instead of advisers to rich men."
Kirk Kerkorian

Partly for historical reasons, there is an abundance of economic indicators relating to industry and commerce in general and manufacturing in particular. These provide useful, timely signals of activity, but it should be borne in mind that their coverage is relatively narrow.

Interpretation

Industrial and commercial indicators provide a guide to both the output and expenditure measures of GDP. These should be used in conjunction with cyclical indicators (page 51) to assess overall economic activity.

Output. The main clues to output include manufacturing and industrial production, car production and sales, construction spending, housing starts and wholesale and retail sales.
	Table 9.1 shows the relative importance of the main sectors. Note that services account for 60-70% of output in the major industrialised countries, but they are relatively neglected among the commonly followed indicators of output. Employment (page 61), consumer spending (page 83) and government consumption (page 31) also provide clues to services.
	It is "value added" that matters - the value of output less the cost of raw materials and other inputs. This is what manufacturlng and industrial production figures measure, but the other indicators are before the deduction of input costs.

Expenditure. The main indicators of industrial and commercial expenditure are fixed investment and investment in stocks (see Chapter 8).
	Fixed investment figures are available only after a lag. This chapter will show that business conditions, construction spending
