<!-- http://www.firstunion.com/reports/2001/0110/monthly0101.pdf -->

Monthly
Economic Outlook
January 10, 2001
Economics
Group

U.S. Overview
The first week of the real new millennium could
hardly have been more dramatic economically.
The extraordinary rate cut by the Fed, and the
exceptionally weak data that propelled it, have
emphatically changed the tone of the economic
debate. Forecasts, including ours, are being
revised sharply downwards. Indeed, to paraphrase
Winston Churchill, seldom have such big changes
been made so quickly by so many.
The suddenness and degree of reported weakness
were startling. November and December were the
coldest since 1895, no doubt exaggerating the
problem to some degree. However, the extent of
new layoffs and corporate credit problems argue
that the potential for real trouble is brewing. The
risk of outright recession has now moved to 50%,
and a hard landing (full year real GDP growth of
less than 2%) in 2001 is the most likely scenario.
The Fed is now on course to lower short term rates
as much as needed to revive both confidence and
activity. Another full percentage point of cuts, to
5.0% by spring, is likely. This dire turn of events
has galvanized not only the Fed, but has also
pushed Congress to endorse cutting taxes. Lower
interest rates and taxes, along with the prospect of
lower energy costs and a lower dollar as 2001
progress are the rationale for assuming a rough
and bumpy landing, but not outright recession.

International Overview
The dollar has depreciated over the past few
weeks as U.S. economic activity has weakened
sharply. Our forecast calls for the greenback to
depreciate further against most major currencies
(excluding the yen) over the next few quarters as
U.S. growth remains weak. However, as recent
(and forthcoming) Fed rate cuts lead to
acceleration in U.S. economic activity later this
year, the dollar should reverse course and
strengthen.
The slowdown in U.S. growth will contribute to
moderation in foreign growth. Therefore, most
foreign central banks eventually should follow the
Feds lead and begin cutting their respective
policy rates. However, because growth in most
foreign countries likely will not weaken as much
as in the United States, foreign central banks
likely will not feel compelled to ease as rapidly
nor as extensively as the Fed.
The deceleration underway in global economic
activity appears to be weighing on Japanese
growth. Therefore, the yen likely will weaken
further over the next few quarters. Similarly, the
currencies of most developing countries should
remain under pressure as long as investors
remain risk averse. However, once global
growth rebounds, the yen and the currencies of
developing countries should reverse course.

U.S. Outlook

In the first week of the new year, there was
startlingly bad news. On the first business day,
Tuesday, the monthly Purchasing Managers
Survey, which Mr. Greenspan has often cited as
one of the most reliable indicators of manufacturing
activity, showed a sharp plunge in December  to a
level not seen since the recession of 1990-91. On
Wednesday, motor vehicle sales for December
were reported and fell off the proverbial cliff. Also
that morning, the weekly report on applications for
mortgages to purchase new homes plunged 21%.
The Fed move was on Wednesday. At that time
they did not have the full employment report, which
came out on Friday, but they did know the data on
manufacturing  which their staff gets early to
compute Industrial Production. So the Fed knew
about the 62,000 decline in manufacturing jobs and
the 2.4% plunge in the length of the factory
workweek  a larger monthly drop in hours worked
than during any month of the 1990-91 recession.
In other words, it was a rude and abrupt return to
work for Mr. Greenspan. (He knew that the awful
weather had some impact on those plunges, but
this was not the time to split statistical hairs.) With
President elect Bushs economic summit in Austin
scheduled for Wednesday, he no doubt heard hoof
beats from that direction as well.
Despite the huge stock rally that afternoon, things
turned worse again on Thursday. The weekly report
on initial unemployment claims spiked up to
375,000, a similar level to the start of the 1990-91
recession, and the Challenger-Grey report on
layoffs showed December quadrupling from
November. Layoff announcements are generally
made ninety days before the actual layoffs occur,
so there should be no comfort in the fact that the
reported unemployment rate for December
remained at 4.0%. Its going up  soon.
The potential bankruptcy of the two largest electric
utilities in California added further fuel to the
concern about corporate credit problems. The credit
crunch of 1989-91 blindsided Mr. Greenspan, so he
is especially sensitive to that potential impact.
Revised Forecast
Several forecasters have recently indicated they
believe the U.S. economy is already in recession.
The fact is that no one, and no model, can divine as
yet if 2001 will see negative real GDP. Forecasting
at this point in a cycle is more intuition than
modeling. There are too many unknowables.
The risk of recession is significant, however, and our
updated forecast, which shows no growth in the 1Q
and 1.5% in the 2Q is meant more to indicate how
tough the early 2001 climate will be than to pretend
we have such precise convictions. If this scenario
plays out, 2001 be the mirror image of 2000. In the
best case, recession fears (with sharp Fed easing) in
early 2001 will prove unfounded, as did the inflation
fears (with sharp Fed tightening) in early 2000.
The key to avoiding negative real GDP figures lies
with the consumer, corporate and bank CEOs, and,
of course, with the Fed.
Consumers were due for a rest. The front page chart
shows a three year moving average of real
spending growth. It has reached a threshold that in
the past has always proven the peak for that cycle.
A spell of subpar spending lies ahead. But, shoppers
have not gone completely on strike. Holiday sales
were not as awful as portrayed in the media. Those
reports focused on same store sales, which rose
only 1% yr/yr. Same store data is appropriate to
use for analyzing companies, but in looking at
overall spending, total sales (including new stores)
is the better tool. Total chain store sales rose 5%
yr/yr, compared with 9% in the 1998 and 99 holiday
seasons. In that vein, and with a projected rise in the
unemployment rate to 4.5%, spending at about half
the pace of recent years looks to be the best bet.
A 5% yr/yr decline in profits in the 2Q now looks
likely, leading to a 2.5% yr/yr decline in business
investment. If a recession does arrive, this sector will
be the culprit. In the 1981-82 and 1990-91
downturns, capital spending fell 10% and 5%,
respectively. Today, businesses want to invest in
technology to raise productivity and reduce costs,
but the necessity to protect the bottom line, the
overcapacity in telecom, and the lesser availability of
risk capital will act to constrain investment.
The Feds task is as much to shore up business
confidence (and therefore investment) as it is to find
the right interest rate to reignite growth. They will
want to achieve both a positively sloped yield curve
(which encourages bank lending) and a stimulative
real fed funds rate. At the current 6.0% nominal
rate, the real rate is 4.3% (based on the core
personal consumption deflator at 1.7%), which is still
restrictive compared to our presumed 3.5%-4.0%
neutral real rate. Projecting a 4.75% fed funds rate
by the 3Q would mean a 2.75% real rate
(assuming the core deflator rises to 2.0% by that
time). We find that a reasonable scenario. Longer
term rates are expected to start rising in the 3Q,
creating a positively sloped yield curve.
Our scenario involves a sharp inventory correction.
Should consumer and capital spending falter more
than projected, however, outright inventory
liquidation would ensue, a sure mark of recession.
Our scenario also assumes relative stability in the
construction markets and a small second half
reversal in the trade deficit (as spending slows). A
federal tax cut supports growth in the second half,
despite slower spending by state governments.

Economic Forecast

International Outlook

Over the past six weeks the dollar has weakened
6% versus sterling and 12% vis--vis the euro. As
shown on the front page, the dollars depreciation
has coincided with a significant narrowing in interest
rate differentials between the United States and the
United Kingdom and Euroland, respectively.
The reasons for the decline in U.S. interest rates
were discussed extensively on page 2. Interest
rates in the United Kingdom and in Euroland also
have fallen over the past few weeks, but much less
markedly than in the United States. During this
period, U.S. economic data generally have indicated
that U.S. growth is slowing sharply. For example,
the NAPM index dropped from 51.8 in July to 43.7 in
December. (Whenever the index is below 50
activity in the manufacturing sector is contracting.)
In contrast, growth rates on the other side of the
pond, although moderating, appear to be holding up
so far. Manufacturing PMIs in the United Kingdom
and Europe remain above 50, indicating that
manufacturing activity continues to expand, albeit at
more moderate rates than a few months ago. No
doubt the relative strength of the dollar versus the
euro and the British pound has contributed to the
relative weakness of U.S. manufacturing production
over the past few months.
We expect that the Bank of England (BoE) and the
European Central Bank will follow the Fed by easing
their respective policy rates. However, we do not
expect these central banks to ease monetary policy
as rapidly or as much as the Fed. As discussed
above, economic activity in the United Kingdom and
in Euroland does not appear to be slowing as quickly
as in the United States. However, the recent decline
in oil prices and the strengthening of those
currencies probably means that inflation rates have
topped out, giving the BoE and the ECB scope to
reduce policy rates. Moreover, these central banks
will want to ease as the slowdown in the United
States contributes to slower growth in the United
Kingdom and Euroland, respectively.
We expect that the dollars depreciation will continue
over the next few quarters as U.S. economic activity
decelerates, causing interest rate differentials to
move further against the greenback. However, the
Fed currently is sowing the seeds of better growth
later this year. As the Feds rate cuts begin to take
effect, causing U.S. growth to pick up, the dollar
should begin to strengthen again going into next
year.
Growth in Canada should moderate over the
course of 2001 as the slowdown in the United States
weighs on Canadian exports. However, the
Canadian economy enters 2001 with more
momentum than its southern counterpart, due in part
to less aggressive tightening last year by the Bank of
Canada relative to the Fed. Moreover, tax cuts that
were legislated last year will begin to take effect this
year, providing support to Canadian consumer
spending. Therefore, the slowdown in Canada likely
will not be as marked as in the United States.
Although the Bank of Canada eventually will follow
the Feds lead by easing policy, the former is not
likely to be as aggressive as the latter. The
Canadian dollar should strengthen against its
southern counterpart in 2001 before weakening
again next year as U.S. dollar strength becomes
generalized.
Japan enters 2001 with its own economic
slowdown underway. The drivers of growth last
year, namely, exports and capital spending appear
to be waning. The growth in the volume of exports
slowed to a year-on-year rate of 5% in the
September-November period, down sharply from
double-digit rates of growth posted over the
summer. Growth in core machinery orders, a good
leading indicator of capital spending, appears to
have topped out, albeit near 30% (year-on-year).
Consumer spending remains sluggish. Although
winter bonuses are expected to be the best in years,
it remains to be seen whether inherently cautious
Japanese consumers will spend these bonuses or
use them to pad their savings accounts.
As long as weakness in Japanese economic activity
persists, the Bank of Japan is likely to leave its
target for the overnight interbank rate at 25 basis
points. However, once global growth begins to firm
next year, the export-dependent Japanese economy
should accelerate again. We project that the yen will
weaken further versus most currencies, including the
dollar, over the next few quarters as doubts about
the Japanese economy persist. However, once
global growth picks up later this year, which will help
brighten the Japanese economic outlook, the yen
should appreciate again.
As long as investors remain risk averse, the
currencies of most developing countries should
remain under pressure. This reasoning underlies
our near-term forecasts for the Singapore dollar, the
Mexican peso, and the Brazilian real. However,
once global growth accelerates anew, causing risk
aversion to abate somewhat, the currencies of most
developing countries should reverse course and
appreciate.
We should note that our foreign forecast is crucially
dependent on our assumption that the United States
averts a bona fide recession. However, if U.S.
growth turns out even weaker than what we project,
economic activity in most foreign countries no doubt
will come in below our forecasts. In that event,
foreign central banks likely would cut their policy
rates more than our current projections.

International Economic Forecast

