<!-- http://www.firstunion.com/reports/2001/0207/monthly0201.pdf -->

Monthly
Economic Outlook
February 7, 2001
Economics
Group

U.S. Overview
On the final Wednesday of January, the Fed sent
the same message as on the first Wednesday of
the month  another half point cut, to 5.50% in the
fed funds rate, saying that circumstances have
called for a rapid and forceful response of
monetary policy. The futures market now expects
another 50bp reduction by the March 20 meeting,
and then a further 25-50bp on May 15. We have
no reason to disagree with that scenario.
The litany of bad news seemed never ending last
month. Conference Board reports showed both
consumer and CEO confidence plunging at a pace
usually seen only during recessions. The
Purchasing Managers survey fell to another new
low. Unemployment rose to 4.2% from 4.0%. 4Q
real GDP slumped to only 1.4%, and Mr.
Greenspan said the 1Q looked to be near zero 
which is our best guess as well.
If there is a glass half full view, it was best said
by Robert McTeer, president of the Dallas Fed,
who called the current problems an air pocket.
The weakness is still narrowly concentrated in
manufacturing and technology, as 54% of all firms
in January, on balance, added new workers. The
construction sector remains solid, and refinancing
is rising. Motor vehicle sales bounced back in
January. Finally, aided by the Fed, corporate bond
issuance surged dramatically in January.

International Overview
With U.S. growth slowing, questions naturally
arise about what effects foreign countries may
feel via deceleration in exports to the United
States. Canada and Mexico, with about one-third
of their respective GDPs comprised of
exports to the United States, are very exposed to
a U.S. economic slowdown. Although not as
dependent as these two North American
countries, many non-Japan Asian economies
also have high trade exposure to the United
States. In contrast, Euroland and Japan are
relatively free from the direct effects of
deceleration in U.S. economic activity.
The Mexican peso and many Asian currencies
have depreciated on balance versus the dollar
since late last year when U.S. economic data
softened sharply. The depreciation of these
currencies versus the greenback suggest that
investors are concerned that the U.S. economic
slowdown may derail growth prospects in these
countries that rely heavily on exports to the
United States. In contrast, the Canadian dollar
has strengthened versus its southern
counterpart. Although Canada has significant
export exposure to the United States, most
investors believe that Canadian domestic
demand is strong enough to weather the U.S.-induced
storm.

U.S. Outlook

Although he is often accused of being intentionally
ambiguous in his public comments, the statement
Mr. Greenspans Fed authored following its meeting
on January 31 was as straightforward and concise
a summary of the current economy as weve seen.
Consumer and business confidence has eroded
further, exacerbated by rising energy costs that
continue to drain consumer purchasing power and
press on business profit margins. Partly as a conse-quence,
retail sales and business spending on
capital equipment have weakened appreciably. In
response, manufacturing production has been cut
back sharply, with new technologies appearing to
have accelerated the response of production and
demand to potential excesses in the stock of
inventories and capital equipment.
4Q Real GDP
Although 4Q data is by definition old news, several
items in that report, released on the same day as the
Fed meeting, emphasized the factors cited in the
Feds statement. The 1.4% real growth (annual rate)
was pulled down by a 4.7% decline in business
investment in equipment and software, and an 0.6%
dip in consumer spending on goods. The rising
energy costs were captured in the fact that real
consumer spending on electricity and natural gas
surged at a 14.8% annual rate, clearly pulling money
away from discretionary goods purchases. Also,
inventory accumulation barely slowed, at $67B vs.
$72B in the 3Q, creating the conditions for the
further production cutbacks announced for the 1Q.
If there was some good news in the report, it was
the narrowness of the most serious trouble. Real
consumer spending on motor vehicles plunged by
12.7%, and business investment in transportation
equipment fell even more, by 37%. Excluding those
two sectors, real GDP rose 2.9% instead of 1.4%.
Consumer spending on recreational services jumped
by almost 11% and on household equipment by 6%.
Business investment in information processing and
software rose 9.6%, which, while mediocre
compared with the 25% average of recent years,
was nevertheless not at recession levels.
Real-Time Information Feedback
The virtues of just-in-time inventory were extolled
continually during the 1990s, but Mr. Greenspan
appears to have detected a downside to the real-time
information flow that fostered such close
inventory monitoring. The same technology that
fostered just-in-time inventory control could also
trigger faster and sharper cutbacks in production at
lower levels of excess inventory (of either
consumer or capital goods) than in past business
cycles. He appears to believe that process was key
to why the economic weakness developed so
suddenly. He has responded by deciding that the
Feds reaction time must also be faster and sharper.
Hence the departure from gradualism.
Another form of real-time information flow that is
rattling confidence is the daily bad news from
California. Rising prices hurt, but an actual
interruption in the supply of energy in a modern
economy is real trouble. Not only is Californias GSP
12% of the U.S. economy, but it accounted for 22%
of all the jobs created in the nation last year (job
growth of 3.1% vs. 1.5% for the nation). It appears
that a short term fix may prevent disaster, but the hit
to confidence will curb expansion plans.
Recession Or Air Pocket?
The manufacturing sector is clearly in recession, but
whether that weakness will spread enough to result
in an official recession is still up in the air. Our
forecast, unchanged from last month, has zero
growth in the 1Q (see page three), recognizing that
the risk is on the downside. The fact that the New
Orders component of Januarys Purchasing
Managers survey dropped sharply again, to its
lowest level since the 1981 recession, and that Non-Defense
Capital Goods Orders ex-aircraft plunged at
an 18% annual rate in the 4Q both argue strongly
that the threat of recession is quite real.
As we mentioned last month, and Mr. Greenspan
emphasized in his testimony, the key factor in
making this transition from supercharged growth
back to sustainable growth without enduring a
deep, prolonged slump is psychology (confidence).
On that front, the recent news is not good, as both
CEO and consumer confidence levels have plunged.
(See front page chart on CEO confidence.) Another
key confidence factor, however, the tone of the
financial markets, has responded well to the Fed.
The stock market is acting as if it believes growth will
resume in the second half. Even more importantly,
from the Feds viewpoint, the corporate bond market
has rebounded strongly, with spreads narrowing and
new issuance in January at a monthly record for
investment grade debt, and at the best January level
ever for high-yield debt.
Finally, it is important to remember that the sharp
deterioration in recent economic data reflects severe
declines in just a few sectors. While they drag down
the aggregate economic figures, they do not mean
the whole economy is in decline. In fact, there is no
such thing as the economy. The varied behavior of
sectors and regions is not able to be captured in
the GDP growth rate. Of the 276,000 layoffs
recorded by Challenger, Grey in December and
January, fully 46% were in just the automotive and
high tech sectors, and 50% were in the Midwest (vs.
only 7% in the South). The distress may well
become more pervasive, but for now air pocket
sounds more correct than recession.

Economic Forecast

International Outlook

As shown on the front page, growth in the volume of
U.S. imports slowed to 11.5% (year-on-year) in the
fourth quarter from 14.6% in Q3. With growth in
U.S. domestic demand projected to moderate further
in the first half of the year, questions naturally arise
about what effects foreign countries may feel via
deceleration in exports to the United States. As the
graph on front page also illustrates, import growth
turned negative during the last U.S. recession and
slowed markedly during 1995s soft landing. Some
of the U.S.s principal trading partners could suffer
significantly if the United States were to slip into
another recession.
The table below shows the export exposure to the
United States that many important U.S. trading
partners have. As seems intuitively plausible,
Mexico and Canada, the U.S.s closest neighbors,
send the vast majority of their exports to the United
States. Moreover, because exports to the United
States account for 27% and 38% of nominal GDP in
Mexico and Canada respectively, both countries are
very exposed to a U.S. economic slowdown.
Japan has much lower relative exposure to the
United States than Mexico and Canada. U.S.
exports account for 31% of Japanese total exports,
but make up only 3% of Japanese nominal GDP.
With U.S. exports accounting for only 3% of GDP,
Euroland also would be relatively unfazed by a U.S.
economic slowdown. However, the trade exposure
of most non-Japan Asian countries to the United
States economy is significantly higher. On average,
these countries send over 20% of their exports to
the United States. Because these Asian countries
are export machines, their economies are
significantly exposed to their respective export
sectors. On average, U.S. exports make up 16% of
these countries nominal GDP.
The graph below shows that the currencies of
Mexico and Korea have weakened versus the dollar
on balance since late last autumn, when economic
data generally started to point in the direction of
significant moderation in U.S. economic growth.
(Currencies of many other Asian countries with
significant export exposure to the United States also
have weakened against the dollar since last
autumn.) The depreciation of these currencies
versus the greenback suggest that investors are
concerned that the U.S. economic slowdown may
derail growth prospects in these countries that rely
heavily on exports to the United States. Note that
the Mexican peso and the Korean won have
appreciated somewhat vis--vis the greenback over
the past few weeks during which the Fed has eased
U.S. monetary policy aggressively. Most investors
believe that these rate cuts (with more expected to
follow) will bolster U.S. growth later this year,
strengthening import growth in the process.
In contrast to the depreciations discussed above, the
Canadian dollar has strengthened versus its U.S.
counterpart since last autumn. Although the
slowdown in the U.S. undoubtedly will exert a
negative effect on Canadian growth, investors
perceive that the Canadian economy will be able to
weather the storm. Final domestic demand (final
sales to consumers, businesses, and government)
grew at an annualized rate of 5.9% in the third
quarter in Canada, outpacing the 3.3% rate
registered in the U.S. during that period. The
Canadian yield curve suggests that the Bank of
Canada will cut its Bank rate to 5% by autumn. If
realized, the Bank will have eased by 100 basis
points. In contrast, the U.S. yield curve is priced for
a fed funds rate of 4.75% by autumn, a cumulative
easing of 175 basis points. Moreover, Canadas
favorable external position may be providing a
favorable backdrop for the currency. It is estimated
that Canada incurred a current account surplus
equal to about 1% of GDP in 2000. In contrast, the
U.S. posted a deficit over 4% of GDP last year.

International Economic Forecast