<!-- http://www.firstunion.com/reports/2001/0410/monthly0401.pdf -->

Monthly
Economic Outlook
April 10, 2001
Economics
Group

U.S. Overview
Analysts continue to render a split decision
regarding the economic outlook. Optimists (and
the Fed) see the solid housing and motor vehicle
climate as signals that consumer spending will
bring the inventory overhang back into balance by
mid-year, allowing production growth to resume
following sharp manufacturing cutbacks in the first
half. Pessimists (and the stock market) see severe
profit pressures and capital spending cutbacks
forcing further layoffs, derailing the consumer, and
pushing the economy into recession. Our view
hangs precariously between the two scenarios:
consumers preventing recession, but weak capital
spending preventing a V shaped rebound.
Should unemployment push above 4.6% by June,
the recession risk would move above 50%.
A fed funds rate of 4.0% is needed to make real
monetary policy stimulative. So far the Fed has
taken its foot off the brake, but not yet really put it
on the gas pedal. The Fed wont ease to suit the
stock market, but will push rates lower until there is
light at the end of the profit tunnel. We see the 3Q
as the probable inflection point, i.e., when
expectations begin to improve. When that
happens, the fortunes of stocks and Treasuries will
reverse. Reversals are processes, not events.
Investors should begin to prepare their portfolios
for the other side of the coin.

International Overview
Although U.S. economic activity continues to
weaken, the dollar has strengthened versus most
currencies over the past month. The dollars
appreciation versus many emerging currencies
reflects the uncertain economic outlook that the
slowdown in the developed world poses for the
developing world. In addition, the dollar likely
has benefited from safe-haven buying as
investors have become more risk averse.
Concerns about yet another recession in Japan
have weighed on the yen. The dollars strength
versus the euro reflects in part investor concerns
that the ECB is falling behind the curve
regarding monetary easing.
Looking forward, we expect that the greenback
will remain well bid against most emerging
currencies until prospects for global growth begin
to improve, probably later this year. Although the
yen likely will depreciate further over the next few
quarters, it too should appreciate once global
growth, and hence Japanese exports,
strengthens. We look for the dollar to depreciate
modestly against the euro over the next few
quarters as forecasts of U.S. growth later this
year are ratcheted down. However, the dollar
should strengthen going into next year as U.S.
economic activity accelerates, enticing foreign
investors with rising real returns on U.S. assets.

U.S. Outlook

An upward revision to January retail sales has put
1Q real consumer spending on track for 3%+
growth, moderately better than the 2.8% of the 4Q.
That uptick has boosted our 1Q real GDP estimate
to 1.3% (from 0.7%) despite a lowered estimate for
capital spending. Based on monthly shipments data
for non-defense capital goods (ex. aircraft), it
appears that 1Q business investment in equipment
and software plunged at a 9% annual rate, almost
three times worse than the 3.3% drop in the 4Q.
With those exceptions, our economic forecast is
essentially unchanged (see page three), straddling
the sanguine Fed view of solid growth in the
second half and the pessimistic recession view. We
do not see real GDP growth moving solidly above
3% until the 2Q of 2002  about a year from now. In
view of the newest round of earning warnings and
the 86,000 decline in employment in March, we
have lowered to 4.0% our estimate of the fed funds
rate necessary to foster a renewal of solid growth.
Consumer Spending & Employment
While the stock markets plunge has dominated the
media in the 1Q, the resiliency of consumer
spending has been equally remarkable. Motor
vehicle sales, which averaged a 17.4 million annual
rate in the 3Q of 2000, plunged to a 15.4 million
pace in December  a key factor in the Feds
emergency rate cut. But despite the negative wealth
effect, surging heating bills, and a barrage of layoffs,
the sales pace rebounded to 17+ million in each
month of the 1Q (March was 17.1 million).
Similarly, the housing market remained solid  starts
still at 1.6 million, new home sales still above
900,000, and existing home resales still at a 5+
million annual rate. The supply/demand situation
remains tilted toward the sellers/builders with
inventories low (at four months vs. a normal six),
and prices rising at 5%-10% depending on location.
No doubt those higher home values, and the surge
in refinancing, are helping to offset the stock market.
If that 1Q pace of consumer activity can be main-tained,
the risk of recession is less than the 40%
probability we assign. Were hopeful, but skeptical -in
light of the zero growth in inflation-adjusted
personal income in January and February plus the
jump in private sector unemployment from 4.0% to
4.5% in the 1Q (government fell to 2.1% from 2.2%).
With March layoff announcements and initial claims
making new cycle highs, and the Manpower Survey
of 2Q hiring intentions dropping sharply, the risks
seem clearly to remain on the downside.
Corporate Profits, CEOs, and The Fed
Were profit growth and margin trends available in
real-time, they would be the ultimate leading
indicator, signaling the expansion or contraction of
corporate intentions to hire (or fire) and to invest (or
retrench). Unfortunately, comprehensive profit data
is available only quarterly and then with a huge lag.
Only on March 29, with the second revision to 4Q
GDP did the first look at total corporate profits
become available. While no secret, due to the string
of earnings releases from S&P 500 companies, the
extent of the decline in operating margins (chart on
front page), confirmed the anxiety of many CEOs.
The margin plunge not only explains the rationale for
cutbacks in hiring and capital spending, but also
calls into doubt the sustainability of productivity
gains seen in recent years. Indeed, for several years
before official data began to confirm an improved
trend in productivity, Mr. Greenspan pointed to profit
margin expansion (in the absence of higher prices)
as a common sense indicator of gains in output per
hour. The Feds emphasis on profit margin
pressures in its statements following recent rate cuts
highlights, in our view, his concern that those
productivity gains could be eroded should real GDP
growth remain subpar for an extended period.
Mr. Greenspans bet the ranch on solid productivity
improvements to hold down inflation, to raise real
wages, to sustain technology investments, and to
keep the Federal Budget in surplus, not to mention
being the crown jewel in his legacy. Reasons
enough, it would seem, for him to get the real fed
funds rate into stimulative territory (2% or less vs.
3%+ currently) sooner rather than later.
"Real" Economy vs. "Financial" Markets
While we expect profits, employment, spending, i.e.,
the real economy, to remain disappointing in 2001,
that does not necessarily mean the stock market will
continue to founder. The financial side of the
economy anticipates the trends in the real
economy  stocks turned down over a year ago, and
Treasuries began their rally on the very day the Fed
did its last rate hike on May 16, 2000. (The 2 Yr.
Note was 6.9% vs. 4.1% currently, and the 10 Yr.
Note was 6.5% vs. 5.0% now.)
If, as we expect, the 2Q of 2002 does mark the
return to solid 3%+ real GDP growth, and if a 4% fed
funds rate in the 3Q of this year marks the end of
Fed easing, then by late summer or fall, stocks will
have seen their cycle lows and Treasury yields will
be headed higher. The September euro-dollars
futures contract is currently priced to yield 4.2%, an
indication that fixed income markets have already
priced in a 4.0% fed funds rate. Unless an actual
recession occurs, and the Fed is forced to lower
rates more than now expected, there shouldnt be
much further downside in Treasury yields. Also, the
safe-haven aspect of the Treasury market rally
during the past year would diminish markedly if the
stock market were again perceived in a positive light
 even if not in an exuberant one.

Economic Forecast

International Outlook

As shown on the front page, the dollar has
strengthened significantly since the beginning of the
year, especially over the past few weeks. Against
major currencies, the dollar has strengthened about
7% since early January (as measured by the Feds
Major Currency index). The greenback also has
appreciated versus the currencies of most
developing countries.
If U.S. economic growth is slowing, why has the
dollar strengthened? The dollars appreciation
versus many emerging currencies may reflect rising
risk aversion among investors. Since the beginning
of the year, equity markets in most countries have
encountered significant selling pressure and yields
on most fixed income securities relative to U.S.
Treasury securities have widened, classic signs of
rising risk aversion. In this sort of financial
environment, investors usually shun investments in
emerging countries. In addition, many developing
countries in Asia are heavily dependent on
production of high-tech goods. The tech wreck
that shows few signs of reversing clouds the outlook
for those countries.
A similar story can be used to explain the dollars
appreciation versus the yen. Because Japanese
domestic demand largely remains stagnant, growth
in that country is heavily dependent on exports,
which have decelerated in line with the slowdown in
global growth, raising concerns that Japan is headed
for recession yet again. In addition, many investors
expect that the Bank of Japan eventually will pump
up the money supply significantly in a last-ditch
effort to jumpstart the moribund economy. As the
supply of yen increases, its value should decline.
The greenbacks strength against the euro and the
British pound is more difficult to explain. Although
growth rates in Europe have moderated recently,
U.S. economic activity has decelerated more
sharply. Some market participants fret that the ECB
is falling behind the curve by keeping rates on
hold, and that Euroland growth in a few quarters will
be weaker than otherwise. This reticence by the
ECB to ease policy stands in sharp contrast with the
Fed, which has cut rates by 150 basis points since
the beginning of the year. In the United States, the
5-year swap rate currently stands about 60 basis
points above the 1-year swap rate. In Euroland, this
differential is only 20 basis points. In general, there
is a positive correlation between the slope of a yield
curve and expectations about future growth.
Looking forward, we expect that the greenback will
strengthen further versus many emerging
currencies. The unfolding slowdown in the
developed world clouds the economic outlook for
many developing countries due to their reliance on
exports of manufactured goods and commodities. In
addition, we expect that the dollar will continue to
benefit from safe-haven flows away from those
currencies. Once the global economic outlook
improves and risk appetites return later this year, we
expect that these currencies will claw their way back
against King Dollar.
We look for the euro and the British pound to
strengthen somewhat versus the greenback over the
next quarter or two. Although growth in Europe is
moderating, which could put downward pressure on
those currencies, our U.S. forecast for the second
half of the year (see page three) is weaker than the
consensus forecast. If we are correct in our views
about the U.S. economy, then the dollar could give
up some of its recent gains as the consensus
growth outlook is scaled back. Once U.S. economic
growth strengthens next year, the dollars upward
trajectory should resume.
We believe that the downside risks to our dollar
forecast largely offset the upside risks. Concerning
the latter, the value of the greenback is no where
near the peak that it reached in February 1985.
Indeed, the Feds Major Currency Index currently is
about 25% below that peak. If, as projected, U.S.
economic growth picks up heading into next year,
the dollar could strengthen even more in the near
term as foreign investors begin to anticipate that
pickup. Although a significantly stronger dollar now
would entail a sharper correction at some point in
the future, further near-term dollar appreciation can
not be ruled out.
However, the constraint imposed by the U.S.
external imbalance is much more binding today than
it was in 1985, and therein lies the biggest downside
risk to our dollar forecast. The dollars strength over
the past few years reflects robust inflows of foreign
capital in search of high real returns. The
counterpart to these strong capital inflows is the
widening current account deficit, which currently
stands at a postwar record of 4.6% of GDP, higher
than the 3.0% deficits that the U.S. racked up in the
mid-80s when the dollar was at its peak. In absolute
terms, the current account deficit totaled $435 billion
last year, and that figure will remain high for the
foreseeable future given the slowdown in growth in
many economies that are important U.S. trading
partners. True, direct investment capital, which is
less sensitive to cyclical considerations, has
accounted for much of the capital inflow over the
past few years. FDI inflows should remain solid.
However, portfolio investors can be fickle. Should
these inflows suddenly weaken, say because foreign
investors have doubts about the U.S. economic
outlook, the large current account deficit, which
represents a net demand for foreign currency, would
exert downward pressure on the dollar.

International Economic Forecast
