<!-- http://www.firstunion.com/reports/2000/1110/monthly1100.pdf -->

Monthly
Economic Outlook
November 10, 2000
Economics
Group

U.S. Overview
For the past six months, economic growth has
been downshifting from the stratospheric orbit of
the past several years back to a more normal
pace. In real GDP terms, the yr/yr increase in the
1Q of 2000 was 6.1% (real consumer spending at
6.0% and real business spending on equipment
and software at 16% - the total dragged down by
the trade deficit). In the 3Q, real GDP was 2.7%.
The financial tailwinds that had supercharged the
1998-99 economy have unwound, leaving the
growth rate to be determined by the interplay of job
growth, raises, inflation, and productivity growth.
In our view, that mix equates to a growth rate of
about 3.5% in real GDP terms, which would fit the
profile of a soft landing. Wall Street, however, is
grappling with concerns of a hard landing, and
what that would imply for corporate profits.
Meanwhile, most of Main Street is oblivious to any
landing (as the campaign rhetoric showed), still
basking in the euphoric glow of its rear view mirror.
The dichotomy between the two groups is striking,
and the paradox explains our outlook.
Due to the tighter conditions in the corporate bond
and syndicated loan market, we no longer view a
Fed rate hike next spring as likely. The financial
markets have done the job for them, preventing a
strong GDP rebound that would have boosted the
core inflation rate beyond 3.0%.

International Overview
Prospects of lower taxes or higher government
spending (depending on who ultimately becomes
president) recall the first Reagan Administration
when easy fiscal policy and tight monetary
policy fueled the dollars sharp appreciation.
Could the greenback strengthen even further
from here?
While the probability of a dollar runup has
increased, we continue to project that the
greenback will weaken modestly going forward.
The U.S. economy is in a much different cyclical
position now than what it was in the early 80s.
The Reagan tax cuts helped pull the economy
out of recession, leading to acceleration in
capital inflows. In contrast, the U.S. economy
has grown for 10 consecutive years, so greater
fiscal stimulus in the current economic
environment, which is characterized by little
excess capacity, could prove to be inflationary.
In our view, the dollars Achilles Heel is the
gaping current account deficit which will swell
even further next year. Because we project that
U.S. economic fundamentals will deteriorate
marginally over the forecast period ( i.e., an
uptick in inflation, somewhat lower growth before
fiscal stimulus kicks in), we do not see capital
inflows strengthening to the extent to offset the
deterioration in the current account.

U.S. Outlook

As we write, the next President is still unknown.
The omission of Mr. Gore/Bushs election as our
next President from our front page overview was
not inadvertent. It was meant to indicate that we
didnt view the election outcome as overly signifi-cant
to the prospects for the economy. The virtual
dead heat only confirms that opinion in our mind.
Actually, if history is any guide, it is Mr.
Bush/Gores misfortune to be elected in a period of
such exceptional prosperity. The lucky presidents
have been those elected when the economy was
in the dumps  Roosevelt, Kennedy, Reagan, and
Clinton. With the natural cyclical tendency for the
economy to improve, they were positioned to take
the credit. Conversely, Hoover, Nixon, Carter, and
Bush, Sr. were not so lucky, having been elected
at the peak of prosperity, and to some degree were
blamed for the inevitable downturn. It doesnt take
a poli-sci degree to project the likely economic
legacy facing Mr. Gore/Bush. What's your guess?
Wall Street Anxiety & Main Street Complacency
The earnings shortfalls on Wall Street  Intel, Dell,
Home Depot, etc.  are very punishing in terms of
the stock price (present value of expected future
earnings). But, the absolute level of their growth,
even at the lower estimates, is not the stuff of
recessions. Similarly, the difficulty in the corporate
bond and syndicated loan markets will slow
expansion plans of larger companies. We expect
operating earnings growth of 7% for the S&P 500
companies (5% for total corporate profits) on a
yr/yr basis by the 4Q of 2001, which is lower than
the current consensus of 10%-12%. However,
there is no sign of a widespread credit crunch, a
la 1989-91, for the broad cross-section of small to
mid-sized business or for consumers. In our view,
the availability of credit for Main Street is key to
avoiding more serious economic trouble.
The financial markets are taming the sectors where
growth had rocketed in recent years, and the
adjustment will be bumpy, even if soft. By
contrast, the huge mainstream of privately owned
companies behave more like a steady river - one
that will support continued, although more
moderate, growth. Finally, should our view prove
overly optimistic, if there is any hint of a consistent
uptrend in unemployment, the Fed could ease and
taxes could be cut. Both monetary and fiscal policy
are in good shape to help in this cycle  monetary
due to the low inflation and fiscal due to the
surplus. In short, the odds favor a more sober
outlook for 2001 than the euphoric environment
that many have come to take for granted, but also
favor making it through the adjustment period
without a recession.
Consumer Spending
After surging at a 6.0% pace during the four quarters
ended in March, real consumer spending has seen a
3.8% annual rate during the 2Q and 3Q. In our view,
a 3.5% pace is sustainable if unemployment remains
near 4.0%, which we expect through mid-2001. So
from that standpoint most of the return to normal in
consumer spending, which is two-thirds of GDP, has
already occurred. If that is the case, then the risk of
recession appears no more than 30%.
We do expect the inventory correction, resulting from
retailers ordering too optimistically earlier this year,
to subtract meaningfully from growth in the next
several quarters. That process, along with slower
export orders, has hurt the manufacturing sector,
contributing to 185,000 lost jobs in recent months.
Business Investment
After surging at a 16.4% pace during the four
quarters ended in June, business spending on
equipment and software rose at an 8.5% annual rate
in the 3Q. In view of more restrained capital
availability, and slower profit growth, weve marked
the outlook for capital spending down a notch in the
4Q and early 2001. Looking at high tech spending,
as shown on the front page, a deceleration from the
almost 30% pace of early 2000 to 15% -20% by late
2001, (our expectation) would slow GDP growth by
0.7 to 1.0 points. We agree there is a competitive
imperative for companies to continue investing in
technology, but believe that with less new funding
(from both internal and external sources),
companies will invest less aggressively than has
been the case in recent years.
Inflation And The Fed
In view of the impact on GDP of further inventory
correction and slower capital spending, we have
lowered our GDP growth rate in the first half of 2001
from 4.5% to 3.5%. That moderation, in combination
with lower oil prices, should prevent inflation from
moving up as strongly as we had expected in 2001,
and thus should allow the Fed to remain on hold
rather than tighten policy further. In effect, the capital
market tightening over the past two months has
done the job that a further Fed tightening would
have done. We do not expect the Fed to change its
balance of risks on November 15, but do expect a
milder tone to its statement.
Since the economy has such strong momentum, a
prolonged period of moderation, rather than a
sudden slump, is the most likely outcome for 2001.
By early in 2002, however, growth could well move
below the Feds desired 3.5%-4.0% pace, which
would hurt the prospects for productivity. At that
point the Fed could see its way to ease policy in
order to insure growth did not slow too much.

Economic Forecast

International Outlook

Following Ronald Reagans election in 1980, the
dollar began a sharp rise that lasted over 4 years
(see front page). The dollars appreciation over that
period that can be explained by the large tax cuts
that went into effect in 1982, thereby stimulating the
economy. In addition, although Fed policy rates
began drifting down in late 1981 as the recession
deepened, monetary policy remained relatively
tight. This mix of loose fiscal policy and tight
monetary policy resulted in high real (i.e., inflation-adjusted)
interest rates that made U.S. investments
look attractive, thereby causing capital to flow into
the United States from abroad. The rise in foreign
demand for dollars (to buy U.S. assets) caused the
greenback to strengthen.
This history lesson is relevant when thinking about
the dollars value going forward. Fiscal policy under
President X will become more expansionary.
(Under Mr. Bush, some form of tax relief likely will be
enacted. Under Mr. Gore, government spending will
increase.) Monetary policy currently is tight, and
we do not project looser policy for some time.
Wont this 80s redux cause the dollar to strengthen
going forward?
While we admit that the probability of a stronger
dollar going forward has risen, we continue to look
for dollar depreciation over the forecast period.
Although the economic policy mix over the next few
years may resemble the stance of fiscal and
monetary policy in the early '80s, the economic
environment today is very different from that earlier
period.
First, the U.S. economy suffered its most severe
postwar recession in the early 80s, and the fiscal
stimulus at that time was needed to pull the
economy out of its slump. Moreover, the high
degree of slack in the economy allowed GDP to
accelerate without generating inflationary pressure.
Thus, U.S. economic fundamentals were well
positioned to attract strong inflows of foreign capital
(see graph below). Indeed, the Dow Jones
Industrial Average broke out of its 17-year trading
range in late 1982. Also that year, the U.S. current
account was essentially in balance.
The U.S. economy is in a much different cyclical
position currently. Following 10 years of expansion
there is very little spare capacity, and fiscal stimulus
could lead to further inflationary pressure. The U.S.
stock market essentially has had an unimpeded rise
for 18 years. Are further strong gains, which likely
would encourage capital inflows, in store going
forward? Maybe, but sooner or later a bear market
has to take hold (doesnt it?).
However, we believe that the dollars Achilles Heel is
the gaping current account deficit, which will exceed
$400 billion this year and is expected to swell to
$450 billion next year (see graph below). Thus,
capital inflows must also accelerate if the dollar is to
strengthen. Because we project that U.S. economic
fundamentals will deteriorate marginally over the
forecast period ( i.e., an uptick in inflation, somewhat
lower growth before fiscal stimulus kicks in) we do
not see capital inflows strengthening to the extent to
offset the deterioration in the current account.
Can the dollar appreciate further from here?
Certainly. The market is forward looking, and it may
begin to discount the effects of greater fiscal
stimulus, although those effects likely will not be felt
for some time. If productivity accelerates, thereby
keeping a lid on inflationary pressures, the expected
combination of robust growth and benign inflation
could further increase the attractiveness of U.S.
assets, leading to acceleration in capital inflows. If
the dollar should appreciate further, however, the
current account deficit will widen even more. Capital
inflows would need to accelerate again. At some
point, the rise in the current account deficit would
become unsustainable. In our view, the more the
dollar strengthens, the more dramatic the inevitable
correction would be.

International Economic Forecast

